2025 MLB Prospects: Baseball America Staff Reveals Their Rankings

0

Image credit: Roki Sasaki (Photo by Yuki Taguchi/WBCI/MLB Photos via Getty Images)

Our 2025 Top 100 Prospects list is a culmination of industry feedback, reporting and input from our staff. Of course, not everyone always aligns completely on how to line up the top prospects in the sport.

Below you can find how members of our staff voted on their personal Top 50 rankings. J.J. Cooper, Geoff Pontes, Matt Eddy and Carlos Collazo participated in this exercise.

Carlos Collazo

RANKPLAYERPOSTEAM
1Roki SasakiRHPLos Angeles Dodgers
2Dylan CrewsOFWashington Nationals
3Roman AnthonyOFBoston Red Sox
4Walker JenkinsOFMinnesota Twins
5Jackson JobeRHPDetroit Tigers
6Chase DollanderRHPColorado Rockies
7Andrew PainterRHPPhiladelphia Phillies
8Noah SchultzLHPChicago White Sox
9Bubba ChandlerRHPPittsburgh Pirates
10Carson WilliamsSSTampa Bay Rays
11Marcelo MayerSSBoston Red Sox
12Kristian Campbell2B/OFBoston Red Sox
13Jordan LawlarSSArizona Diamondbacks
14Leodalis De VriesSSSan Diego Padres
15Sebastian WalcottSSTexas Rangers
16Bryce Eldridge1BSan Francisco Giants
17Samuel BasalloCBaltimore Orioles
18Colt EmersonSSSeattle Mariners
19Emmanuel RodriguezOFMinnesota Twins
20Jesus MadeSSMilwaukee Brewers
21Kevin McGonigleSS/2BDetroit Tigers
22Travis Bazzana2BCleveland Guardians
23JJ WetherholtSSSt. Louis Cardinals
24Jaison ChourioOFCleveland Guardians
25Ethan SalasCSan Diego Padres
26Jasson DominguezOFNew York Yankees
27Dalton RushingCLos Angeles Dodgers
28Coby Mayo3BBaltimore Orioles
29Max ClarkOFDetroit Tigers
30Nick Kurtz1BOakland Athletics
31Charlie Condon3BColorado Rockies
32Thomas WhiteLHPMiami Marlins
33Quinn MathewsLHPSt. Louis Cardinals
34Matt Shaw3BChicago Cubs
35Rhett LowderRHPCincinnati Reds
36Angel GenaoSSCleveland Guardians
37Kumar RockerRHPTexas Rangers
38Hagen SmithLHPChicago White Sox
39Aidan MillerSSPhiladelphia Phillies
40Chase BurnsRHPCincinnati Reds
41Jacob WilsonSSOakland Athletics
42Cade HortonRHPChicago Cubs
43Drake BaldwinCAtlanta Braves
44Chase DeLauterOFCleveland Guardians
45Cole YoungSS/2BSeattle Mariners
46Kyle TeelCChicago White Sox
47Owen CaissieOFChicago Cubs
48Jett WilliamsSSNew York Mets
49Colson MontgomerySSChicago White Sox
50Jeferson QueroCMilwaukee Brewers

Geoff Pontes

RANKPLAYERPOSTEAM
1Roki SasakiRHPLos Angeles Dodgers
2Roman AnthonyOFBoston Red Sox
3Kristian Campbell2B/OFBoston Red Sox
4Jackson JobeRHPDetroit Tigers
5Bubba ChandlerRHPPittsburgh Pirates
6Walker JenkinsOFMinnesota Twins
7Chase DollanderRHPColorado Rockies
8Jordan LawlarSSArizona Diamondbacks
9Andrew PainterRHPPhiladelphia Phillies
10Jesus MadeSSMilwaukee Brewers
11Carson WilliamsSSTampa Bay Rays
12Travis Bazzana2BCleveland Guardians
13Colt EmersonSSSeattle Mariners
14Sebastian WalcottSSTexas Rangers
15Leodalis De VriesSSSan Diego Padres
16Emmanuel RodriguezOFMinnesota Twins
17Noah SchultzLHPChicago White Sox
18Jasson DominguezOFNew York Yankees
19Chase BurnsRHPCincinnati Reds
20Dylan CrewsOFWashington Nationals
21Bryce Eldridge1BSan Francisco Giants
22Matt Shaw3BChicago Cubs
23JJ WetherholtSSSt. Louis Cardinals
24Nick Kurtz1BAthletics
25Kumar RockerRHPTexas Rangers
26Samuel BasalloCBaltimore Orioles
27Hagen SmithLHPChicago White Sox
28Thomas WhiteLHPMiami Marlins
29Coby Mayo3BBaltimore Orioles
30Jaison ChourioOFCleveland Guardians
31Quinn MathewsLHPSt. Louis Cardinals
32Max ClarkOFDetroit Tigers
33Ethan SalasCSan Diego Padres
34Marcelo MayerSSBoston Red Sox
35Josue De PaulaOFLos Angeles Dodgers
36Charlie Condon3BColorado Rockies
37Dalton RushingCLos Angeles Dodgers
38Cade HortonRHPChicago Cubs
39Kevin McGonigleSS/2BDetroit Tigers
40Rhett LowderRHPCincinnati Reds
41Angel GenaoSSCleveland Guardians
42Jeferson QueroCMilwaukee Brewers
43Chase DeLauterOFCleveland Guardians
44Jacob MisiorowskiRHPMilwaukee Brewers
45Tink HenceRHPSt. Louis Cardinals
46Cooper PrattSSMilwaukee Brewers
47Cole CarriggOF/SSColorado Rockies
48Alejandro RosarioRHPTexas Rangers
49Ricky TiedemannLHPToronto Blue Jays
50Jett WilliamsSSNew York Mets

J.J. Cooper

RANKPLAYERPOSTEAM
1Roki SasakiRHPLos Angeles Dodgers
2Roman AnthonyOFBoston Red Sox
3Jackson JobeRHPDetroit Tigers
4Kristian Campbell2B/OFBoston Red Sox
5Walker JenkinsOFMinnesota Twins
6Chase DollanderRHPColorado Rockies
7Noah SchultzLHPChicago White Sox
8Carson WilliamsSSTampa Bay Rays
9Dylan CrewsOFWashington Nationals
10Andrew PainterRHPPhiladelphia Phillies
11Bryce Eldridge1BSan Francisco Giants
12Bubba ChandlerRHPPittsburgh Pirates
13Samuel BasalloCBaltimore Orioles
14Jordan LawlarSSArizona Diamondbacks
15Leodalis De VriesSSSan Diego Padres
16Colt EmersonSSSeattle Mariners
17Marcelo MayerSSBoston Red Sox
18Emmanuel RodriguezOFMinnesota Twins
19Max ClarkOFDetroit Tigers
20Kevin McGonigleSS/2BDetroit Tigers
21Jesus MadeSSMilwaukee Brewers
22Coby Mayo3BBaltimore Orioles
23Rhett LowderRHPCincinnati Reds
24Matt Shaw3BChicago Cubs
25Dalton RushingCLos Angeles Dodgers
26Travis Bazzana2BCleveland Guardians
27Charlie Condon3BColorado Rockies
28Chase BurnsRHPCincinnati Reds
29Hagen SmithLHPChicago White Sox
30Jaison ChourioOFCleveland Guardians
31Nick Kurtz1BAthletics
32Thomas WhiteLHPMiami Marlins
33JJ WetherholtSSSt. Louis Cardinals
34Jasson DominguezOFNew York Yankees
35Kumar RockerRHPTexas Rangers
36Jacob WilsonSSAthletics
37Sebastian WalcottSSTexas Rangers
38Cade HortonRHPChicago Cubs
39Quinn MathewsLHPSt. Louis Cardinals
40Colson MontgomerySSChicago White Sox
41Ethan SalasCSan Diego Padres
42Kyle TeelCChicago White Sox
43Angel GenaoSSCleveland Guardians
44Luke Keaschall2BMinnesota Twins
45Alejandro RosarioRHPTexas Rangers
46Cole YoungSS/2BSeattle Mariners
47Alex FreelandSSLos Angeles Dodgers
48Owen CaissieOFChicago Cubs
49Moises BallesterosCChicago Cubs
50Drake BaldwinCAtlanta Braves

MATT EDDY

RANKPLAYERPOSTEAM
1Roki SasakiRHPLos Angeles Dodgers
2Roman AnthonyOFBoston Red Sox
3Jackson JobeRHPDetroit Tigers
4Andrew PainterRHPPhiladelphia Phillies
5Walker JenkinsOFMinnesota Twins
6Bryce Eldridge1BSan Francisco Giants
7Kristian Campbell2B/OFBoston Red Sox
8Carson WilliamsSSTampa Bay Rays
9Jordan LawlarSSArizona Diamondbacks
10Dylan CrewsOFWashington Nationals
11Noah SchultzLHPChicago White Sox
12Chase DollanderRHPColorado Rockies
13Samuel BasalloCBaltimore Orioles
14Bubba ChandlerRHPPittsburgh Pirates
15Leodalis De VriesSSSan Diego Padres
16Sebastian WalcottSSTexas Rangers
17Thomas WhiteLHPMiami Marlins
18Chase BurnsRHPCincinnati Reds
19Colt EmersonSSSeattle Mariners
20Jesus MadeSSMilwaukee Brewers
21Max ClarkOFDetroit Tigers
22Jaison ChourioOFCleveland Guardians
23Dalton RushingCLos Angeles Dodgers
24Ethan SalasCSan Diego Padres
25Coby Mayo3BBaltimore Orioles
26Jasson DominguezOFNew York Yankees
27JJ WetherholtSSSt. Louis Cardinals
28Jacob WilsonSSAthletics
29Kevin McGonigleSS/2BDetroit Tigers
30Emmanuel RodriguezOFMinnesota Twins
31Charlie Condon3BColorado Rockies
32Travis Bazzana2BCleveland Guardians
33Quinn MathewsLHPSt. Louis Cardinals
34Colson MontgomerySSChicago White Sox
35Marcelo MayerSSBoston Red Sox
36Hagen SmithLHPChicago White Sox
37Rhett LowderRHPCincinnati Reds
38Kumar RockerRHPTexas Rangers
39Matt Shaw3BChicago Cubs
40Cade HortonRHPChicago Cubs
41Nick Kurtz1BAthletics
42Cam Smith3BHouston Astros
43Jacob MisiorowskiRHPMilwaukee Brewers
44Cooper PrattSSMilwaukee Brewers
45Konnor GriffinSS/OFPittsburgh Pirates
46Bryce RainerSSDetroit Tigers
47Jac Caglianone1BKansas City Royals
48Jeferson QueroCMilwaukee Brewers
49Jett WilliamsSSNew York Mets
50Brandon SproatRHPNew York Mets

Download our app

Read the newest magazine issue right on your phone