BA Newsletter: Get Analysis, Rankings Delivered To Your Inbox!

College Player Of The Year: Lewis Powers Away From Field



SEE ALSO: Baseball America Awards

As a recruit, Kyle Lewis didn’t exactly fit Mercer’s mold.

The Bears look for players ready to contribute quickly. Lewis wasn’t going to be that guy, his attention always having been divided between baseball and basketball. Still, between his athleticism, his intelligence and his tools—even if he only showed them in flashes—Mercer coaches decided he was worth bringing in.

College Player Of The Year
1981Mike Sodders, 3b, Arizona State
1982Jeff Ledbetter, of/lhp, Florida State
1983Dave Magadan, 1b, Alabama
1984Oddibe McDowell, of, Arizona State
1985Pete Incaviglia, of, Oklahoma State
1986Casey Close, of, Michigan
1987Robin Ventura, 3b, Oklahoma State
1988John Olerud, 1b/lhp, Washington State
1989Ben McDonald, rhp, Louisiana State
1990Mike Kelly, of, Arizona State
1991David McCarthy, 1b, Stanford
1992Phil Nevin, 3b, Cal State Fullerton
1993Brooks Kieschnick, dh/rhp, Texas
1994Jason Varitek, c, Georgia Tech
1995Todd Helton, 1b/lhp, Tennessee
1996Kris Benson, rhp, Clemson
1997J.D. Drew, of, Florida State
1998Jeff Austin, rhp, Stanford
1999Jason Jennings, rhp, Baylor
2000Mark Teixeira, 3b, Georgia Tech
2001Mark Prior, rhp, Southern California
2002Khalil Greene, ss, Clemson
2003Rickie Weeks, 2b, Southern
2004Jered Weaver, rhp, Long Beach State
2005Alex Gordon, 3b, Nebraska
2006Andrew Miller, lhp, North Carolina
2007David Price, lhp, Vanderbilt
2008Buster Posey, c/rhp, Florida State
2009Stephen Strasburg, rhp, San Diego State
2010Anthony Rendon, 3b, Rice
2011Trevor Bauer, rhp, UCLA
2012Mike Zunino, c, Florida
2013Kris Bryant, 3b, San Diego
2014A.J. Reed, 1b/lhp, Kentucky
2015Andrew Benintendi, of, Arkansas
2016Kyle Lewis, of, Mercer

“He was just an athletic piece and his skill level wasn’t there (as a high schooler),” Mercer head coach Craig Gibson said. “So he’s generally not what we sign. We like more guys that are a little more skilled, that can come in and play immediately. But he was a guy we took a chance on—that we thought if his skill level ever caught up with his athleticism, he’s going to be a good player.”

The skill level did catch up. Three years later, Lewis will leave as the program’s new gold standard. “He’s the best player in school history,” Gibson said.

Lewis’ statistics read like something out of another era—a .395/.535/.731 slash line in 61 games. Although Mercer’s season ended in the finals of the Southern Conference tournament, at the time, Lewis ranked among the top five nationally in total bases, slugging and on-base percentage. Mercer’s coaches are quick to point out his nation-leading 66 walks cost him roughly 15 games of at-bats too, meaning he did did his greatest damage—his 20 homers and 72 RBIs—as if he played in 45 games.

With that level of domination, on top of being one of college baseball’s premier talents, Lewis is Baseball America’s 2016 College Player of the Year.

Even though the thunderous power in his bat is usually the first thing mentioned in any Lewis scouting report, he doesn’t think of himself as a home run hitter. For Lewis, home runs are just a by-product of trying to hit balls on a line, a mentality that would make any hitting coach proud.

“I’m not trying to go up there and just slug home runs and swing for the fences. I’m trying to put hard line drives in play consistently,” Lewis said. “I think that if you try to hit low line drives consistently that you’ll get the elevation and you’ll get some balls out of the park, and I’ve been able to do that. But I think that as an overall hitter, I try to just be a hitter for average.”

Lewis hit a 461-foot moon shot over the batter’s eye at Fluor Field in the SoCon tournament that was as majestic as a home run can be—a ball down the middle, his front foot down, full extension on his arms. The blast elicited oohs and ahs from the crowd and the video of it spread quickly on Twitter. In the Bears’ dugout though, it wasn’t anything they hadn’t seen before. Just Kyle doing his thing.

“That’s nothing abnormal for Kyle,” teammate Trey Truitt said afterward. “Kyle does that all the time.”

Team Player

After not playing every day as a freshman, Lewis took off as a sophomore last year. He hit .367/.423/.677 with 17 homers in the spring for Mercer, then tore up the prestigious Cape Cod League over the summer, hitting .300/.344/.500 and ranking as the Cape’s No. 3 prospect.

Packs of scouts have followed Lewis ever since. But even with his hometown team, the Braves, owning the third overall pick, Lewis doesn’t let his mind wander. Sure, he’s thought about the draft, but so long as he was wearing a Mercer uniform, the Bears were his priority.

“We’ll have 15-30 or more scouts at each game,” Mercer assistant coach and recruiting coordinator Brent Shade said. “He knows that they’re there, but he puts it out of his mind and just goes about his business and lets his play do the talking for him. He’s a team guy, I will tell you that. He’s all about Mercer first and Kyle second. That’s hard to find guys like that.”

Jared Mckenzie Courtesybaylor

Baylor Baseball: Five Questions to Answer Entering 2022

Baylor narrowly missed the NCAA Tournament last season. In 2022, it has a roster that should prevent it from being left out again.

Lewis led the Bears to back-to-back SoCon regular-season titles in 2015 and 2016, winning conference player of the year honors in both. Suffice to say that chance the Bears took paid off. “I don’t know what’s to come,” Lewis said, “but it’s going to be fun.”

Are you a member?

In order to access this exclusive content you must have a Baseball America Account. 

Login or sign up  


Additionally, you can subscribe to Baseball America's newsletter and receive all of our rankings, analysis, prospect insight & more delivered to your inbox every day. Click here to get started. 

of Free Stories Remaining