BA Newsletter: Get Analysis, Rankings Delivered To Your Inbox!

Glaser: MLB's Playoff Proposal Won't Fix Its Problems



The New York Post reported Monday that Major League Baseball is considering an expanded postseason where 14 of the league’s 30 teams would make the playoffs and the top teams would get to pick their opponents.

Regardless of whether the best postseason format is the past or present one, it certainly is not this future one.

MLB should be working hard to be less like the NHL and NBA when it comes to the postseason, not more. Those are the leagues that feature roughly half of all teams making the playoffs, and we know what happens.

Teams with losing records get in. No one remembers what happens in the first round. The regular season is irrelevant. Making the playoffs becomes a meaningless accomplishment.

One of baseball’s most valuable assets is its playoff teams have proved undeniably worthy. After 162 games, the teams who make it have earned it.

Adopt this proposal and MLB throws that all away. Devalue the 162-game regular season to the point that even teams who barely finish above .500—as the seventh-best teams in each league, the Red Sox (84-78) and D-backs (85-77) did last year—can call themselves playoff teams, and making the playoffs becomes little more than a participation trophy. In 2017, there would have been a three-way tie for the sixth-best record in the American League—all three teams (the Angels, Royals and Rays) finished at 80-82.

All that in the name of satisfying broadcast partners, who, by the way, are already paying MLB more than a combined $1 billion per year and are zero threat to suddenly just stop carrying MLB games. MLB doesn’t need radical changes to survive in the modern media landscape.

Baseball is already dealing with a number of long-term problems, from the increasing length of game times to declining attendance to a sign-stealing scandal that has created a crisis in credibility.

Embracing mediocrity to generate superficial excitement is not a fix to MLB’s problems. It would just create new ones.

How They Would Have Finished
MLB's reported playoff proposal would expand the playoffs to seven teams in each league. Here is how many wins the seventh place team finished with in each of the past 19 seasons.
YearALWinsNLWins
2019Boston84Arizona85
2018Seattle89Three-way tie82
2017Three-way tie80St. Louis83
2016Two-way tie86Miami79
2015Minnesota83Washington83
2014Cleveland85Two-way tie79
2013Two-way tie85Arizona81
2012Los Angeles89Milwaukee83
2011Toronto81Los Angeles82
2010Toronto85Colorado83
2009Tampa Bay84Atlanta86
2008Toronto86Two-way tie86
2007Toronto83Atlanta84
2006Toronto87Cincinnati80
2005Minnesota83Two-way tie83
2004Chicago83San Diego87
2003Two-way tie86Two-way tie85
2002Chicago81Montreal83
2001Boston82Two-way tie86
Kebryanhayes Justinberlgetty

Podcast: Expanded Postseason Thoughts And Rookie Favorites For 2021

Breaking down the merits of expanding the postseason beyond this year, plus some under-the-radar rookies to watch.

of Free Stories Remaining