Click Here To Visit Our Sponsor
BA Online - Scoreboards

Top Ten Prospects: Pittsburgh Pirates
Complete Index of Top 10s

By John Perrotto
November 23, 2005

Baseball America's Top 10 Prospects lists are based on projections of a player's long-term worth after discussions with scouting and player-development personnel. All players who haven't exceeded the major league rookie standards of 130 at-bats or 50 innings pitched (without regard to service time) are eligible. Ages are as of April 1, 2006.

Scouting reports for the Top 10 Prospects (Subscribers only) -- Click Here to Subscribe

Chat Wrap: John Perrotto took
your Pirates questions
Pre-Order the 2006 Prospect Handbook
for 30 scouting reports on every team

1. Neil Walker, c
2. Andrew McCutchen, of
3. Tom Gorzelanny, lhp
4. Paul Maholm, lhp
5. Jose Bautista, 3b
6. Nate McLouth, of
7. Bryan Bullington, rhp
8. John Van Benschoten, rhp
9. Chris Duffy, of
10. Matt Capps, rhp
Best Hitter for Average Andrew McCutchen
Best Power Hitter Jose Bautista
Best Strike-Zone Discipline Andrew McCutchen
Fastest Baserunner Pedro Powell
Best Athlete Neil Walker
Best Fastball Tom Gorzelanny
Best Curveball Jason Quarles
Best Slider Josh Sharpless
Best Changeup Joe Bauserman
Best Control Paul Maholm
Best Defensive Catcher Ronny Paulino
Best Defensive Infielder Brent Lillibridge
Best Infield Arm Javier Guzman
Best Defensive Outfielder Andrew McCutchen
Best Outfield Arm Brad Corley
Team Player, Pos. 2005 Org
1996 Jason Kendall, c Athletics
1997 Kris Benson, rhp Mets
1998 Kris Benson, rhp Mets
1999 Chad Hermansen, of Out of baseball
2000 Chad Hermansen, of Out of baseball
2001 J.R. House, c Out of baseball
2002 J.R. House, c Out of baseball
2003 John Van Benschoten, rhp Pirates
2004 John Van Benschoten, rhp Pirates
2005 Zake Duke, lhp Pirates
Team Player, Pos. 2005 Org
1996 Kris Benson, rhp Mets
1997 J.J. Davis, of Rockies
1998 Clint Johnston, lhp/of Blue Jays
1999 Bobby Bradley, rhp Pirates
2000 Sean Burnett, lhp Pirates
2001 John Van Benschoten, rhp Pirates
2002 Bryan Bullington, rhp Pirates
2003 Paul Maholm, lhp Pirates
2004 Neil Walker, c Pirates
2005 Andrew McCutchen, of Pirates
Bryan Bullington, 2002 $4,000,000
John Van Benschoten, 2001 $2,400,000
Bobby Bradley, 1999 $2,225,000
Paul Maholm, 2003 $2,200,000
Kris Benson, 1996 $2,200,000

The Pirates have been stressing the importance of a small-market franchise being able to build from within ever since Kevin McClatchy put together an ownership group that took control of the club on the first day of spring training in 1996. After years of trying, Pittsburgh began practicing what it has preached the second half of the 2005 season.

The Pirates began the season without one rookie on their roster. Before their 13th consecutive losing season ended, though, 12 players had made their major league debuts. That began a full-scale youth movement that the Pirates believe eventually can lead them back to respectability.

Pittsburgh’s long-suffering fans were enthused by the play of such youngsters as lefthanders Zach Duke and Paul Maholm; catcher Ryan Doumit; first baseman Brad Eldred; and outfielders Chris Duffy and Nate McLouth. Duke had the best debut at 8-2, 1.81 and finished fifth in the National League rookie of the year race. Lefty Tom Gorzelanny, righties Bryan Bullington, Matt Capps and Ian Snell, catcher Ronny Paulino, third baseman Jose Bautista and infielder J.J. Furmaniak also made cameo appearances.

“As far as having players who can help us in the future, this is the best position we’ve been in since I got here,” said general manager Dave Littlefield, who replaced Cam Bonifay midway through the 2001 season.

While the focus was on the rookies at the end of 2005, Pittsburgh also saw other players make significant progress in their second full major league seasons.

Left fielder Jason Bay built on his NL rookie-of-the-year award by hitting .306-32-101 with 21 steals in 22 attempts while starting all 162 games. Second baseman Jose Castillo began to develop power, hitting .268-11-53 in 101 games before a knee injury ended his season in late August.

The Pirates also have high hopes for 23-year-old lefthander Oliver Perez, who slipped to 7-5, 5.85 in 20 starts and missed nearly two months with a broken big toe after he kicked a metal laundry cart in frustration. He went 12-10, 2.98 with 239 strikeouts in 196 innings in 2004.

The Pirates stressed patience in player development when Littlefield took over and brought in Brian Graham as farm director and Ed Creech as scouting director. Instead of fast-tracking players to the majors, they moved them one level at a time for the most part. The players who arrived in Pittsburgh in 2005 didn’t appear overwhelmed by the surroundings.

Under Graham, Pirates farm clubs have posted a combined winning record in each of the last four seasons. Prior to that, they finished above .500 just once in 33 years.

Pittsburgh’s strength in recent years clearly has been pitching. However, that’s starting to change as the Pirates used the 11th overall pick in the last two drafts on a pair of high school position players, catcher Neil Walker (2004) and center fielder Andrew McCutchen (2005). They rank 1-2 on our Pirates Top 10 Prospects list this year.

Scouting reports for the Top 10 Prospects (Subscribers only) -- Click Here to Subscribe