RoboScout 2025 Fantasy Baseball Dynasty Rankings For Every Position

We’ve essentially reached the midpoint of the 2025 season, meaning it’s a good time to check in on RoboScout and curate updated prospect rankings for each position.

In the past, we’ve done an overall ranking that combines the leaders at each level into a single aggregated list. The difficulty with this approach is in trying to figure out where to slot a young, lower-level hitter with high upside against a Triple-A slugger who is on the precipice of debuting but is already 25 years old.

Our 2025 rankings are based on peak projections derived from a player’s current-year performance. RoboScout regresses a player—and this pertains to pitchers, also—according to historical age curves and minors-to-majors equivalency curves. From this, an estimated peak major league projection is calculated for each player. The likelihood of reaching said projection, based on a player’s current minor league level, is then blended in to the calculation.

Naturally, peak projection derived from performance at a lower level is considered to be less reliable than a similar peak projection derived from upper-level performance. This adjustment downwardly affects lower-level performers the most, so to compensate, the performance of a prospect relative to his peers at the same level helps boost the top performers. As such, a player who is far outperforming his peers at Low-A, for example, should not have the full effect of that downward adjustment applied to them.

We’ve also separated hitters from pitchers, as the value of pitchers varies greatly depending on league format. For example, pitchers are not nearly as good an investment in roto leagues as they are in H2H formats.

Below, you’ll find RoboScout’s rankings of the top performers are every position, plus an overall ranking of the 75 hitters. Players are listed with their estimated peak MLB projections based on 600 plate appearances.

Catcher

rank	player	level	xba	xobp	wRC+	hr	sb
1	Samuel Basallo	AAA	0.278	0.367	131	35	1
2	Josue Briceno	A+	0.274	0.354	117	36	2
3	Rainiel Rodriguez	A	0.264	0.340	110	26	3
4	Eduardo Tait	A	0.266	0.332	105	28	2
5	Leonardo Bernal	AA	0.269	0.340	111	24	9
6	Moises Ballesteros	AAA	0.275	0.343	113	18	4
7	Alfredo Duno	A	0.263	0.347	111	20	3
8	Harry Ford	AAA	0.263	0.342	109	18	4
9	Ethan Salas	AA	0.265	0.341	101	17	12
10	Thayron Liranzo	AA	0.241	0.327	102	23	1

First Base

rank	player	level	xba	xobp	wrc+	hr	sb
1	Bryce Eldridge	AAA	0.269	0.338	109	28	2
2	Ryan Clifford	AA	0.252	0.335	113	27	4
3	Brooks Baldwin	AAA	0.261	0.329	114	24	10
4	Esmerlyn Valdez	A+	0.253	0.322	110	28	2
5	Xavier Isaac	AA	0.245	0.335	108	25	3
6	Blaze Jordan	AAA	0.269	0.336	106	20	4
7	Jac Caglianone	AAA	0.268	0.337	106	29	4
8	C.J. Kayfus	AAA	0.249	0.326	109	19	5
9	Chris Suero	A+	0.240	0.314	99	25	22
10	Nick Kurtz	AAA	0.246	0.320	106	24	2

Second Base

rank	player	level	xBA	xOBP	wrc+	HR	sb
1	Kevin McGonigle	A+	0.279	0.351	117	25	3
2	Sal Stewart	AA	0.274	0.341	118	21	13
3	Andrew Salas	A	0.254	0.334	98	13	17
4	Michael Arroyo	AA	0.271	0.349	122	25	3
5	Cole Young	AAA	0.278	0.352	114	17	6
6	Colt Emerson	A+	0.265	0.337	100	18	4
7	Max Anderson	AA	0.274	0.337	122	22	3
8	Pedro Ramirez	AA	0.266	0.333	108	15	17
9	William Bergolla	AA	0.285	0.346	106	9	19
10	Jeral Perez	A+	0.242	0.307	93	28	3

Shortstop

rank	player	level	xba	xobp	wrc+	hr	sb
1	Luis Pena	A	0.284	0.349	116	23	30
2	Jesus Made	A	0.268	0.345	110	17	24
3	Leo De Vries	A+	0.268	0.346	108	21	6
4	Konnor Griffin	A+	0.265	0.333	114	24	24
5	Sebastian Walcott	AA	0.269	0.348	114	23	16
6	Jordan Lawlar	AAA	0.254	0.331	112	22	23
7	Arjun Nimmala	A+	0.261	0.330	101	25	4
8	A.J. Ewing	A+	0.259	0.335	102	13	35
9	Nacho Alvarez Jr.	AAA	0.267	0.349	111	17	4
10	George Lombard Jr.	AA	0.256	0.339	107	13	19
11	Ryan Ritter	AAA	0.253	0.330	110	24	5
12	Cooper Pratt	AA	0.270	0.340	104	15	17
13	Caleb Bonemer	A	0.253	0.332	101	17	15
14	Jefferson Rojas	A+	0.262	0.335	99	17	13
15	Franklin Arias	A+	0.274	0.334	99	16	7
16	Mikey Romero	AA	0.253	0.324	108	21	6
17	Bryce Rainer	A	0.252	0.324	99	22	12
18	Adrian Santana	A+	0.268	0.330	94	13	24
19	JJ Wetherholt	AA	0.269	0.348	111	13	14
20	Wyatt Sanford	A	0.244	0.315	92	17	25

Third Base

rank	name	level	xBA	xOBP	wRC+	HR	SB
1	Luke Adams	AA	0.270	0.354	123	23	11
2	Brock Wilken	AA	0.255	0.347	121	29	3
3	Eric Bitonti	A	0.233	0.310	98	30	7
4	Kyle Karros	AA	0.263	0.339	114	14	8
5	Rosman Verdugo	A+	0.229	0.312	95	25	3
6	Jacob Reimer	AA	0.263	0.337	120	19	9
7	Jose Fermin	AAA	0.268	0.340	107	11	24
8	Yandel Ricardo	A	0.259	0.328	108	17	21
9	Jesus Baez	A+	0.257	0.325	94	21	7
10	Aidan Miller	AA	0.242	0.319	95	16	28

Outfielders

rank	player	level	xba	xobp	wrc+	HR	SB
1	Eduardo Quintero	A	0.269	0.350	123	27	22
2	Jett Williams	AA	0.270	0.354	124	17	23
3	Theo Gillen	A	0.258	0.347	110	22	26
4	Lazaro Montes	AA	0.263	0.347	125	29	3
5	Hector Rodriguez	AA	0.278	0.347	117	22	6
6	Josue De Paula	A+	0.260	0.343	105	21	18
7	Nelson Rada	AA	0.272	0.349	114	12	26
8	Edward Florentino	A	0.263	0.338	115	26	11
9	Max Clark	A+	0.266	0.350	106	18	10
10	Braylon Payne	A	0.240	0.317	95	20	20
11	Slade Caldwell	A+	0.250	0.338	107	15	13
12	Dylan Beavers	AAA	0.256	0.332	107	17	22
13	Zyhir Hope	A+	0.249	0.326	103	17	9
14	Nate George	A	0.255	0.321	103	18	24
15	Walker Jenkins	AA	0.249	0.330	101	17	20
16	Justin Crawford	AAA	0.266	0.340	111	12	28
17	Henry Bolte	AA	0.247	0.323	105	18	26
18	Spencer Jones	AAA	0.259	0.336	110	38	13
19	Asbel Gonzalez	A	0.258	0.322	90	10	39
20	Luis Lara	AA	0.264	0.339	103	10	22

RoboScsout’s Top 75 Overall Hitters

Below are the top 75 hitters per RoboScout, with their estimated major league peak projections, extrapolated to 600 plate appearances (including the catchers):

rank	player	level	xBA	xOBP	wRC+	hr	SB
1	Samuel Basallo	AAA	0.278	0.367	131	35	1
2	Luis Pena	A	0.284	0.349	116	23	30
3	Eduardo Quintero	A	0.269	0.350	123	27	22
4	Josue Briceno	A+	0.274	0.354	117	36	2
5	Jesus Made	A	0.268	0.345	110	17	24
6	Leo De Vries	A+	0.268	0.346	108	21	6
7	Jett Williams	AA	0.270	0.354	124	17	23
8	Luke Adams	AA	0.270	0.354	123	23	11
9	Kevin McGonigle	A+	0.279	0.351	117	25	3
10	Theo Gillen	A	0.258	0.347	110	22	26
11	Konnor Griffin	A+	0.265	0.333	114	24	24
12	Sebastian Walcott	AA	0.269	0.348	114	23	16
13	Rainiel Rodriguez	A	0.264	0.340	110	26	3
14	Bryce Eldridge	AAA	0.269	0.338	109	28	2
15	Eduardo Tait	A	0.266	0.332	105	28	2
16	Sal Stewart	AA	0.274	0.341	118	21	13
17	Jordan Lawlar	AAA	0.254	0.331	112	22	23
18	Lazaro Montes	AA	0.263	0.347	125	29	3
19	Hector Rodriguez	AA	0.278	0.347	117	22	6
20	Josue De Paula	A+	0.260	0.343	105	21	18
21	Nelson Rada	AA	0.272	0.349	114	12	26
22	Leonardo Bernal	AA	0.269	0.340	111	24	9
23	Ryan Clifford	AA	0.252	0.335	113	27	4
24	Brooks Baldwin	AAA	0.261	0.329	114	24	10
25	Arjun Nimmala	A+	0.261	0.330	101	25	4
26	Andrew Salas	A	0.254	0.334	98	13	17
27	Michael Arroyo	AA	0.271	0.349	122	25	3
28	Edward Florentino	A	0.263	0.338	115	26	11
29	Max Clark	A+	0.266	0.350	106	18	10
30	Brock Wilken	AA	0.255	0.347	121	29	3
31	Braylon Payne	A	0.240	0.317	95	20	20
32	A.J. Ewing	A+	0.259	0.335	102	13	35
33	Esmerlyn Valdez	A+	0.253	0.322	110	28	2
34	Nacho Alvarez Jr.	AAA	0.267	0.349	111	17	4
35	Moises Ballesteros	AAA	0.275	0.343	113	18	4
36	Cole Young	AAA	0.278	0.352	114	17	6
37	Alfredo Duno	A	0.263	0.347	111	20	3
38	George Lombard Jr.	AA	0.256	0.339	107	13	19
39	Slade Caldwell	A+	0.250	0.338	107	15	13
40	Dylan Beavers	AAA	0.256	0.332	107	17	22
41	Ryan Ritter	AAA	0.253	0.330	110	24	5
42	Colt Emerson	A+	0.265	0.337	100	18	4
43	Cooper Pratt	AA	0.270	0.340	104	15	17
44	Xavier Isaac	AA	0.245	0.335	108	25	3
45	Blaze Jordan	AAA	0.269	0.336	106	20	4
46	Eric Bitonti	A	0.233	0.310	98	30	7
47	Zyhir Hope	A+	0.249	0.326	103	17	9
48	Caleb Bonemer	A	0.253	0.332	101	17	15
49	Harry Ford	AAA	0.263	0.342	109	18	4
50	Jac Caglianone	AAA	0.268	0.337	106	29	4
51	Nate George	A	0.255	0.321	103	18	24
52	Jefferson Rojas	A+	0.262	0.335	99	17	13
53	Franklin Arias	A+	0.274	0.334	99	16	7
54	Mikey Romero	AA	0.253	0.324	108	21	6
55	Max Anderson	AA	0.274	0.337	122	22	3
56	Bryce Rainer	A	0.252	0.324	99	22	12
57	Pedro Ramirez	AA	0.266	0.333	108	15	17
58	Adrian Santana	A+	0.268	0.330	94	13	24
59	William Bergolla	AA	0.285	0.346	106	9	19
60	Walker Jenkins	AA	0.249	0.330	101	17	20
61	Ethan Salas	AA	0.265	0.341	101	17	12
62	JJ Wetherholt	AA	0.269	0.348	111	13	14
63	Justin Crawford	AAA	0.266	0.340	111	12	28
64	C.J. Kayfus	AAA	0.249	0.326	109	19	5
65	Henry Bolte	AA	0.247	0.323	105	18	26
66	Spencer Jones	AAA	0.259	0.336	110	38	13
67	Asbel Gonzalez	A	0.258	0.322	90	10	39
68	Chris Suero	A+	0.240	0.314	99	25	22
69	Nick Kurtz	AAA	0.246	0.320	106	24	2
70	Kyle Karros	AA	0.263	0.339	114	14	8
71	Rosman Verdugo	A+	0.229	0.312	95	25	3
72	Luis Lara	AA	0.264	0.339	103	10	22
73	Hendry Mendez	AA	0.271	0.342	108	15	6
74	Jeral Perez	A+	0.242	0.307	93	28	3
75	Wyatt Sanford	A	0.244	0.315	92	17	25

Below are the top 40 pitchers, per RoboScout (aka ThrowboScout) along with their estimated peak major league projections. To help contextualize the rankings, most of the names below should be rostered in leagues of 12 teams or more.

Pitchers

rank	Player	level	k%	bb%	gb%	xERA	xWHIP
1	Chase Burns	AAA	26%	5%	45%	3.22	1.06
2	Jack Perkins	AAA	30%	8%	44%	3.71	1.12
3	Michael McGreevy	AAA	22%	5%	52%	3.52	1.16
4	Logan Henderson	AAA	26%	6%	40%	3.72	1.14
5	Jacob Misiorowski	AAA	27%	7%	44%	3.65	1.16
6	Cam Schlittler	AAA	25%	7%	48%	3.63	1.18
7	Joe Boyle	AAA	26%	8%	51%	3.56	1.18
8	Cristian Mena	AAA	24%	6%	47%	3.79	1.15
9	David Festa	AAA	24%	6%	46%	3.70	1.15
10	Jonah Tong	AA	28%	8%	55%	3.26	1.17
11	Ian Seymour	AAA	23%	6%	39%	3.93	1.17
12	Travis Sykora	A+	30%	8%	45%	3.52	1.10
13	Trey Yesavage	A+	28%	9%	45%	3.86	1.20
14	Mick Abel	AAA	23%	7%	49%	3.77	1.21
15	Jacob Lopez	AAA	27%	7%	43%	3.88	1.15
16	Didier Fuentes	AAA	21%	5%	44%	3.89	1.19
17	Payton Tolle	AA	27%	7%	41%	3.64	1.15
18	Sean Linan	AAA	23%	7%	47%	3.97	1.20
19	Yordanny Monegro	AA	24%	7%	52%	3.42	1.18
20	Tekoah Roby	AAA	21%	6%	45%	4.00	1.22
21	Luinder Avila	AAA	23%	7%	47%	3.86	1.21
22	Blade Tidwell	AAA	24%	7%	43%	4.03	1.20
23	J.T. Ginn	AAA	26%	8%	49%	3.80	1.20
24	Noah Cameron	AAA	23%	7%	49%	3.81	1.23
25	AJ Smith-Shawver	AAA	23%	7%	46%	3.92	1.20
26	Eduardo Rivera	AA	26%	8%	54%	3.61	1.21
27	Zebby Matthews	AAA	22%	6%	47%	3.90	1.21
28	Mitch Bratt	AA	22%	5%	42%	3.83	1.16
29	Brandon Young	AAA	21%	6%	46%	4.05	1.23
30	Brandon Walter	AAA	22%	6%	54%	3.83	1.20
31	Bubba Chandler	AAA	25%	7%	46%	3.76	1.18
32	Coleman Crow	AA	22%	7%	49%	3.68	1.22
33	Chase Petty	AAA	22%	7%	45%	3.96	1.22
34	Luis Morales	AAA	23%	7%	44%	4.06	1.21
35	David Davalillo	AA	22%	6%	51%	3.71	1.22
36	Trey Gibson	AA	25%	8%	48%	3.74	1.23
37	Gage Stanifer	A+	27%	9%	49%	3.70	1.21
38	Gage Jump	A+	22%	7%	44%	4.01	1.24
39	Troy Melton	AAA	23%	6%	41%	3.90	1.19
40	Mike Burrows	AAA	25%	7%	43%	3.96	1.19