Drafted in the 2nd round (74th overall) by the Milwaukee Brewers in 2009 (signed for $492,200).
View Draft Report
In a banner year for prep catchers, Garfield stands out as one of the best pure defenders. At 6-feet and 190 pounds, Garfield is fit, strong and powerful. His pop times range from 1.85 to 1.90 seconds at showcase events, with one scout clocking a 1.78, and he has an above-average arm. Scouts' primary worry is that Garfield shines at showcases and struggles in games. He often puts on eye-opening power exhibitions during batting practice, but he has trouble carrying those results into games. He has a breathtakingly quick bat, but he often pulls off the ball and opens his front side, pulling the ball hard but foul. Failure to track the pitch and let it get deep throws off his timing, though he will occasionally show the ability to stay back on the breaking ball. Doubts may exist about Garfield's bat, but few doubts exist about his defense. His bat shows the promise of power, but he'll need improvement to bring it up to big league average.
Top Rankings
Organization Prospect Rankings
If Garfield looked overmatched at times in 2010 in low Class A, that was to be expected. He began the season at age 18 and had only 59 games of Rookie ball experience under his belt. He really struggled offensively, having difficulty getting on base consistently and showing little power. Garfield does have some pop in his bat, however, and the Brewers believe his power will develop with physical maturity, more at-bats and the understanding that he must use his hands more. He probably won't hit for a high average but should be able to hold his own enough at the position. Defensively, Garfield improved as the season progressed in both receiving and blocking balls. Opponents ran wild on Wisconsin's pitchers last season, and while Garfield displayed a strong arm, his erratic footwork cost him time and accuracy. Runners were able to steal 140 bases (in 173 attempts, an 81 percent success rate) in just 101 games. Milwaukee likes the leadership skills he shows behind the plate and thinks he will continue to improve in all areas of the game. He has a good head on his shoulders and understands what he must do to improve. Despite his young age, Garfield will move up to high Class A this year.
Download our app
Read the newest magazine issue right on your phone