Yanks Deftly Spin Move to Third
by Alan Schwarz
NEW YORK--Eric Chavez hates it. A shortstop his whole life, Chavez moved to third base after being drafted by the A’s. He handled it so well that he has won three straight Gold Glove awards.
And yet he hates third base.
"I don’t feel comfortable," Chavez said. "When I’m playing third, I feel cut off. Every time I move over to short for Thome for the shift, I’m like, ‘This is what baseball’s supposed to look like.’ "
Baseball is supposed to have Alex Rodriguez playing shortstop, but the reigning MVP and two-time Gold Glove winner is now going to move to third base, in deference to the inferior defender (and PR man), Derek Jeter. Talk about cut off--Rodriguez’ developing legacy as the best all-around shortstop in baseball history was suddenly sliced and tossed away like one of George Steinbrenner’s cigar ends.
Our view has changed, as will that of Rodriguez. In moving over to third base his entire perspective will change: he’ll have to barehand bunts; backhand screamers down the line with reflexes considerably quicker than he ever required before. He does this having played not one inning as a professional at any position other than shortstop; at least Cal Ripken had played the position before. And Rodriguez does it in New York, where this hot corner is more like a crucible.
"I haven’t spoken to anyone about playing third base," Rodriguez said. "This is all very new to me."Derek Demurs
Yankees personnel spent most of the press conference at Rodriguez’ unveiling trying to spin why--when everyone from scouts to statheads rate Jeter the inferior defender--their better shortstop is playing third base. "Because someone maybe has more ability, and can do certain things, doesn’t mean you’re a better team that way," manager Joe Torre offered. "It’s something that you can’t put down on paper."
Then I will: The Yankees simply don’t want to dis Derek--their captain and key member of six pennant winners--and are willing to open a can of worms with this move, rather than a keg, by having Rodriguez shift instead. But with Rodriguez’ ability and attitude, his end of that can should close pretty quick. (Jeter’s will be pried open further with every misplay, which is silly but inevitable.)
The Yankees have assigned their former third base star, Graig Nettles, to work with Rodriguez in spring training on all the new moves he’ll need. Balls will spin differently, and arrive faster. Rodriguez can handle that--he has great first steps to his left and right--but playing back will ease the transition.
"Like me, he could play deep and play the position almost like short," Nettles said. "You can get better hops when you play deep. If you play up close, you’re at the mercy of whatever happens."
Mark Newman, the Yankees VP of baseball operations, sees Rodriguez having to adjust even before the pitcher winds up. At shortstop, Rodriguez could see the catcher’s signs and knew the planned location of every pitch; now he will have to get signs from Jeter. And with Rodriguez now off one side, his view of the action is less direct.
"At third base you have to watch the ball and then pick up the plate at some point," Newman said. "You can lose the ball a little bit on the way to the plate, and then you have to pick up this 90-mph orb in the hit zone."From Arky To Alex
Others, of course, have made this switch and thrived. Mike Schmidt moved just as his career began, Ripken as his ended. Two Hall of Famers did it mid-career: Joe Sewell (with Cleveland in 1929) and Arky Vaughan (when traded from Pittsburgh to Brooklyn in 1942).
Many onlookers see Rodriguez’ overall athleticism and see him making the switch deftly, taking spring training to be competent, one full year to be good, and the next to add another Gold Glove to his mantel. Ripken himself commented, "He’s got great hands and great instincts for the game. Adjusting to a new position always presents challenges at first, but nothing practice and game experience won’t take care of."
The same could have been told to Jeter, but the organization insulated him from baseball’s bombshell by not even asking about third, or even second. Jeter got testy when reporters did it instead. "I’m playing short now. That’s my job here," he said. "His job here now is to play third base." One Yankees official told me of the club’s approach to this one: "Who could play where best was not the issue."
So Rodriguez, one of the great athletes of our time, will now begin his crash course at third and hope not to muck up what has been an outstanding defensive resume. Perhaps he really will win a Gold Glove in his new home.
As for Chavez? He won’t mind. By that time, he will surely have escaped the trappings of third base, playing second for the Yankees.