Cleveland Indians
By Chris Kline
January 16, 2008
Baseball America's Top 10 Prospects lists are based on projections of a player's long-term worth after discussions with scouting and player-development personnel. All players who haven't exceeded the major league rookie standards of 130 at-bats or 50 innings pitched (without regard to service time) are eligible. Ages are as of April 1, 2008.
TOP
TEN
PROSPECTS |
| 1. |
Adam Miller, rhp |
| 2. |
Chuck Lofgren, lhp |
| 3. |
Beau Mills, 3b/1b |
| 4. |
Wes Hodges, 3b |
| 5. |
Aaron Laffey, lhp |
| 6. |
Nick Weglarz, of |
| 7. |
Jordan Brown, of |
| 8. |
David Huff, lhp |
| 9. |
Ben Francisco, of |
| 10. |
Jensen Lewis, rhp |
|
BEST
TOOLS |
| Best Hitter for
Average |
Jordan
Brown |
| Best Power
Hitter |
Beau
Mills |
| Best Strike-Zone
Discipline |
Jordan
Brown |
| Fastest
Baserunner |
Jose
Constanza |
| Best
Athlete |
Brad
Snyder |
| Best
Fastball |
Adam
Miller |
| Best
Curveball |
Scott
Lewis |
| Best
Slider |
Adam
Miller |
| Best
Changeup |
David
Huff |
| Best
Control |
David
Huff |
| Best Defensive
Catcher |
Wyatt
Toregas |
| Best Defensive
Infielder |
Adam
Davis |
| Best Infield
Arm |
Josh
Rodriguez |
| Best Defensive
Outfielder |
Brad
Snyder |
| Best Outfield
Arm |
Brad Snyder |
|
PROJECTED 2011
LINEUP |
| Catcher |
Victor Martinez |
| First Base |
Ryan Garko |
| Second
Base |
Asdrubal
Cabrera |
| Third
Base |
Beau Mills |
| Shortstop |
Jhonny Peralta |
| Left
Field |
Nick
Weglarz |
| Center
Field |
Grady
Sizemore |
| Right
Field |
Franklin
Gutierrez |
| Designated
Hitter |
Travis
Hafner |
| No. 1
Starter |
C.C.
Sabathia |
| No. 2
Starter |
Fausto
Carmona |
| No. 3
Starter |
Adam
Miller |
| No. 4 Starter |
Chuck Lofgren |
| No. 5
Starter |
Aaron
Laffey |
| Closer |
Rafael Perez |
|
TOP PROSPECTS
OF THE
DECADE |
| Year |
Player,
Position |
2007 |
| 1998 |
Sean
Casey, 1b |
Tigers |
| 1999 |
Russell
Branyan, 3b |
Cardinals |
| 2000 |
C.C.
Sabathia, lhp |
Indians |
| 2001 |
C.C.
Sabathia, lhp |
Indians |
| 2002 |
Corey
Smith, 3b |
Newark
(Atlantic) |
| 2003 |
Brandon
Phillips, ss/2b |
Reds |
| 2004 |
Grady
Sizemore, of |
Indians |
| 2005 |
Adam
Miller, rhp |
Indians |
| 2006 |
Adam
Miller, rhp |
Indians |
| 2007 |
Adam
Miller, rhp |
Indians |
|
TOP DRAFT PICKS
OF THE
DECADE |
| Year |
Player, Position |
2007 |
| 1998 |
C.C.
Sabathia, lhp |
Indians |
| 1999 |
Will
Hartley, c (2nd) |
Out of
baseball |
| 2000 |
Corey
Smith, 3b |
Newark
(Atlantic) |
| 2001 |
Dan
Denham, rhp |
Athletics |
| 2002 |
Jeremy
Guthrie, rhp |
Orioles |
| 2003 |
Michael
Aubrey, 1b |
Indians |
| 2004 |
Jeremy
Sowers, lhp |
Indians |
| 2005 |
Trevor
Crowe, of |
Indians |
| 2006 |
David
Huff, lhp |
Indians |
| 2007 |
Beau
Mills, 3b/1b |
Indians |
|
LARGEST BONUSES
IN CLUB
HISTORY |
| Danys Baez,
1999 |
$4,500,000 |
| Jeremy Guthrie,
2002 |
$3,000,000 |
| Jeremy Sowers,
2004 |
$2,475,000 |
| Michael Aubrey,
2003 |
$2,010,000 |
| Dan Denham,
2001 |
$1,860,000 |
|
INDIANS
LINKS |
|
|

While their season ended
in disappointing fashion, the Indians completed their rebuilding project by
returning to the top of the American League Central. The organization had been
pointing toward that goal since Mark Shapiro took over as general manager after
the 2001 season, the last time Cleveland
had gone to the playoffs. Shapiro's administration immediately tore down an
expensive roster and began assembling younger talent.
The
Indians won 93 games in 2005 and looked well on their way back, but a faulty
bullpen contributed to a 78-84 finish in 2006. Their young core matured last
season and showed that the step back in '06 was the
anomaly.
What will linger in Cleveland fans' memories, however, is how
much better it could have been. The Tribe knocked off the Yankees in the AL
Division Series, then pushed the Red Sox to seven games in the AL Championship
Series. The most frustrating part was that the Indians had Boston on the ropes with a 3-1 series lead
with a chance to clinch at Jacobs Field. But Josh Beckett turned the tide in
Game Five, starting a run of three straight wins for the Red Sox that dashed
the Indians' hopes of their first World Series title since
1948.
"I'm disappointed obviously we weren't able to
finish it off," manager Eric Wedge said. "I'm proud as I could be of our
players. We fell short, but I think we learned a great deal in this
postseason."
The good news is that the remade Indians are
equipped to go on the same kind of run they enjoyed from 1995-2001, when they
went to the playoffs six times in seven years. While a primary focus of
Shapiro's rebuilding efforts centered around homegrown contributors such as
Fausto Carmona, Victor Martinez, Jhonny Peralta and C.C. Sabathia, the pro
scouting department helped build the club as much, if not more, than the
amateur department.
Recognizing the talent of Grady Sizemore
while he was in Class A or Travis Hafner when he was in Triple-A paid huge
dividends. So did stealing Asdrubal Cabrera from the Mariners in a trade for
Eduardo Perez.
After graduating several players to the big
leagues, the farm system is at a crossroads. The system still has depth, but
aside from oft-injured righthander Adam Miller, no true blue-chip prospects are
waiting in the wings.
And aside from holdovers liked
Miller, no new faces outside of Double-A first baseman Jordan Brown separated
themselves from the pack in 2007. The system was wracked by injury and lack of
performance last year, as lefthander Tony Sipp had Tommy John surgery,
outfielder Brad Snyder went down with a broken thumb in July and the two top
draft picks from 2005 (outfielders Trevor Crowe and John Drennen) were
disappointments.
Double-A Akron and high Class A Kinston
were again powerhouse clubs in the minor leagues, though both teams lost in the
postseason. Kinston's
87 victories were the third-highest total in the
minors..
The Indians had just one pick in the first three
rounds of the 2007 draft, selecting slugger Beau Mills 13th overall. Two of
their later-round picks have a lot of upside, as the club went over slot to
sign Florida high school lefthander Chris Jones (15th round) for $350,00 and
Oregon prep two-way standout Joey Mahalic (32nd round) for $123,000.