| BEST HITTER |
| 1. | Ichiro Suzuki, Mariners |
| 2. | Derek Jeter, Yankees |
| 3. | Magglio Ordonez, Tigers
|
| BEST POWER |
| 1. | Alex Rodriguez, Yankees |
| 2. | Justin Morneau, Twins |
| 3. | Vladimir Guerrero, Angels
|
| BEST BUNTER |
| 1. | Ichiro Suzuki, Mariners |
| 2. | Kenny Lofton, Rangers |
| 3. | Luis Castillo, Twins
|
| BEST STRIKE-ZONE JUDGMENT |
| 1. | Travis Hafner, Indians |
| 2. | Bob Abreu, Yankees |
| 3. | Placido Polanco, Tigers
|
| BEST HIT-AND-RUN ARTIST |
| 1. | Placido Polanco, Tigers |
| 2. | Derek Jeter, Yankees |
| 3. | Orlando Cabrera, Angels
|
| BEST BASERUNNER |
| 1. | Ichiro Suzuki, Mariners |
| 2. | Brian Roberts, Orioles |
| 3. | Derek Jeter, Yankees
|
| FASTEST BASERUNNER |
| 1. | Carl Crawford, Devil Rays |
| 2. | Ichiro Suzuki, Mariners |
| 3. | Joey Gathright, Royals
|
| MOST EXCITING PLAYER |
| 1. | Ichiro Suzuki, Mariners |
| 2. | Grady Sizemore, Indians |
| 3. | Carl Crawford, Devil Rays
|
| BEST PITCHER |
| 1. | Johan Santana, Twins |
| 2. | Dan Haren, Athletics |
| 3. | Josh Beckett, Red Sox
|
| BEST FASTBALL |
| 1. | Justin Verlander, Tigers |
| 2. | Joel Zumaya, Tigers |
| 3. | Felix Hernandez, Mariners
|
| BEST CURVEBALL |
| 1. | Josh Beckett, Red Sox |
| 2. | Justin Verlander, Tigers |
| 3. | Francisco Rodriguez, Angels
|
| BEST SLIDER |
| 1. | Jeremy Bonderman, Tigers |
| 2. | Scott Kazmir, Devil Rays |
| 3. | C.C. Sabathia, Indians
|
| BEST CHANGEUP |
| 1. | Johan Santana, Twins |
| 2. | James Shields, Devil Rays |
| 3. | Daisuke Matsuzaka, Red Sox
|
| BEST CONTROL |
| 1. | Paul Byrd, Indians |
| 2. | Johan Santana, Twins |
| 3. | Roy Halladay, Blue Jays
|
| BEST PICKOFF MOVE |
| 1. | Andy Pettitte, Yankees |
| 2. | Kenny Rogers, Tigers |
| 3. | Mark Buehrle, White Sox
|
| BEST RELIEVER |
| 1. | Jonathan Papelbon, Red Sox |
| 2. | J.J. Putz, Mariners |
| 3. | Mariano Rivera, Yankees
|
| BEST DEFENSIVE CATCHER |
| 1. | Ivan Rodriguez, Tigers |
| 2. | Joe Mauer, Twins |
| 3. | Jason Varitek, Red Sox
|
| BEST DEFENSIVE FIRST BASEMAN |
| 1. | Mark Teixeira, Rangers |
| 2. | Carlos Pena, Devil Rays |
| 3. | Casey Kotchman, Angels
|
| BEST DEFENSIVE SECOND BASEMAN |
| 1. | Luis Castillo, Twins |
| 2. | Placido Polanco, Tigers |
| 3. | Brian Roberts, Orioles
|
| BEST DEFENSIVE THIRD BASEMAN |
| 1. | Eric Chavez, Athletics |
| 2. | Adrian Beltre, Mariners |
| 3. | Mike Lowell, Red Sox
|
| BEST DEFENSIVE SHORTSTOP |
| 1. | Derek Jeter, Yankees |
| 2. | Orlando Cabrera, Angels |
| 3. | Yuniesky Betancourt, Mariners
|
| BEST INFIELD ARM |
| 1. | Adrian Beltre, Mariners |
| 2. | Brandon Inge, Tigers |
| 3. | Yuniesky Betancourt, Mariners
|
| BEST DEFENSIVE OUTFIELDER |
| 1. | Ichiro Suzuki, Mariners |
| 2. | Torii Hunter, Twins |
| 3. | Vernon Wells, Blue Jays
|
| BEST OUTFIELD ARM |
| 1. | Ichiro Suzuki, Mariners |
| 2. | Vladimir Guerrero, Angels |
| 3. | Delmon Young, Devil Rays
|
| BEST MANAGER |
| 1. | Jim Leyland, Tigers |
| 2. | Mike Scioscia, Angels |
| 3. | Ron Gardenhire, Twins |