Top 25 Chat: May 11
Aaron Fitt will chat about the weekend in college baseball and the Top 25 beginning at 2:30 p.m. ET.
Grant (Phoenix): No Josh Spence again this weekend for ASU. When is he due back?
Hi everyone, welcome to the top 25 chat.
Bad news for Sun Devils fans: Spence has a strained tendon in his
middle finger and is unlikely to pitch again this year, though there is
a very slim chance he could try to pitch out of the bullpen again this
year. That's horrible news for the Sun Devils, but let's not bury their
chances — maybe Jason Franzblau is up to the task of filling Spence's
shoes. He sure did a nice job with that this weekend.
Henry (Nashville): Bryce Brentz had a big
weekend both on the mound and at the plate. Is he the best 2 way player
right now not named Brooks Raley, and is he a possible 1st round pick
in the 2010 draft?
Yes and yes. And Brentz can give Raley a
serious run for his money. That's saying something, considering one
coach told me this year that Raley might be the best player ever in the
history of the Big 12. At this very early juncture, Bryce Brentz looks
like a very strong bet to be a first-round pick next year—the guy is a
Corey (Gainesville): What does Florida have to do to secure a regional host? Are they still in the running for a national seed?
Still in strong position to host, and that
RPI (sixth, according to Boyd's World) means the Gators still have a
good shot at a national seed, too. In order to host, they simply need
to avoid falling on their faces next week against Kentucky and in the
SEC tournament. A strong SEC tournament run could very well give them a
national seed. After LSU, the SEC is quite muddled right now. I think
Ole Miss, Alabama and Florida will be separated down the stretch. At
this point, it appears all three of them have separated themselves from
Georgia and Arkansas, both of whom got cold at the wrong time.
Robert (Va.): Does George Mason have any shot
at an at-large bid with a series win over JMU and a decent showing in
the CAA tourney? Have you seen a league as jumbled in the middle as the
CAA this year?
I actually addressed this a bit in Three
Strikes today (which should be posted shortly) — I do think the
Patriots are in strong position to to earn an at-large bid as a backup
plan. Sure, their resume doesn't have many quality wins, but they'll be
rewarded for their consistency and solid RPI. As for the CAA, this is
nothing too unusual — remember 2007, when there was a four-way tie for
Adam (Miami): What are your thoughts on the Sun Belt Conf? How many bids will they get and will FIU be one of them?
At least two, probably three. The Panthers
really helped themselves this weekend by sweeping South Alabama, but
their RPI (61st) is still not great, and Troy (52nd in the RPI, a game
better in the conference standings) is also playing well right now and
has the inside track at the Sun Belt's third bid, behind Western
Kentucky and Middle Tennessee State. The Blue Raiders are not a lock
yet, but I like their chances and their talent.
Harry (Jackson, MS): What must the Ole Miss Rebels do to host a regional and is becoming a national seed out of the question?
It could come down to next weekend at
Arkansas. If the Hogs sweep or maybe even win two out of three, they
could steal Mississippi's hosting slot. I still like Mississippi's
chances though. If the Rebels win that series and make a deep run in
Hoover, I could see them getting back into the national seed
discussion. Like I said, the SEC is still very open right now after LSU.
Ben (Atlanta by way of Baton Rouge): Besides
Ranaudo, Coleman, and Ott, it seems the Tiger's pitching staff
struggles. They get a good game from Ross occasionally, but he just
doesn't seem to be as clutch as the other three. Do they have enough
arms to make it through the regionals and deep into Omaha?
That is the question with LSU, and I think
your assessment is spot-on. But LSU and UC Irvine are the top two teams
in the nation right now, and both lean heavily on three pitchers (in
Irvine's case, it's Bibona, Bergman and Pettis). If you've got three
money guys, you can go a long way by riding whichever arms are hot
after that — especially when you have a talented offense capable of
getting hot and carrying you for a while, like LSU has. So, yes, I
think they have enough arms to make a very deep postseason run.
Wes Porter (Yuba City, California): What a
year it has been for the WAC. There has not been one team who has
maintained a top spot in the standings all year. At this point, it
seems like it is up in the air in who will win the league tournament
and earn a spot in a regional. What is your take on the WAC and what do
you see happening in the WAC tournament?
Right now San Jose State looks like the
best team in that league; certainly the Spartans have been the most
consistent, going 10-1-1 in weekend series this year. That's a solid if
not explosive club, and right now I think that's who I'll take in the
WAC tournament — but really, it's a crapshoot. I wouldn't be surprised
by any team in that league winning the tournament. It all depends who
gets hot at the right time.
Brian (Charleston, SC): Do you see a scenario where 5 teams from the ACC would host a regional? I know the SEC has had 5 teams host recently.
I don't think it's too likely, because the
SEC and Big 12 also have no shortage of worthy hosts. But some very
strong hosting candidates are going to be left out in the cold in the
ACC. Florida State and Georgia Tech are locks, and UNC will host as
well barring a collapse over the next two weeks in line with what
happened in Raleigh this past weekend. Right now, I think Virginia has
the inside track over Clemson for the fourth spot, with Miami falling
back after this weekend. Clemson is still a very big factor in this
Tyler (OC, California): Aaron, With UCI
holding onto the top spot for the past couple of weeks, do you think
any of their players are going to be worthy of a top two round draft
consideration either in this years draft or the 2010 draft.
The 'Eaters really have no players with a
chance to go in the top two rounds this year or next — it's just a
bunch of skilled, unflappable veterans who play extremely well
together. My draft sleeper for them is a freshman for 2011: Tommy
Reyes. He might have the most raw talent on the team, and he's made a
nice impact as a freshman.
Brandon (Fayetteville,Ar): Am I going to be watching the Hogs play regional baseball at home?
I don't think so, but it's not too late to turn it around. Momentum can shift in a hurry, especially in the SEC.
Ross (Richmond, Va): Elon joined the poll at
#22 this week, is there any chance of them slipping into a 1 seed if
they win out in the conf tourny? Also what chances would you give them
of reaching a Super Reagional?
I really have a hard time seeing the
Phoenix as a No. 1 seed, despite their RPI and the way they obliterated
the SoCon. It's just not a great record against area powers like UNC
and ECU, and the Pirates would probably get a crack at a No. 1 seed
before Elon. As for Elon's regional chances, I'd say that offense is
capable of bludgeoning its way to super regionals, but I'd worry that a
quality pitching staff like UNC's or Virginia's or Clemson's could slow
those bats down a bit, and Elon's pitching does not look up to the task
of carrying the burden.
John (Atlanta, GA): Do you think Cal State Fullerton has a good enough team to make it to the college world series? Do you think they will win?
Yes, and quite possibly. I will be quite
surprised if the Titans aren't in Omaha, and they are on my short list
of top national title contenders. Honestly, I still have them higher on
that list than UC Irvine, despite the Anteaters' amazing season. But
both are legitimate national title contenders.
Matt (Bakersfield, CA): Please tell me that
UC-Irvine has assured itself of hosting a Regional and (if they advance
a) Super Regional at this point with the lofty record and resume.
Between UCI, Fullerton, and ASU, which West coast teams are in line to
That's a lock. It better be, because I am
planning to shuttle back and forth between Irvine and Fullerton for
regionals! All three of those teams will host.
Kanten (Sanford, NC): Carolina's offense
struggled this past weekened in Raleigh, Is this a cause for concern
for the Heels or will they get it together.....
It is cause for concern because Jimmy
Gillheeney reinforced that the Tar Heels can be silenced by a quality
lefthander. Then again, Jimmy Gillheeney won't be in the NCAA
tournament, and there aren't a lot of other Gillheeneys out there...
Pat Murphy (Tempe, AZ): Can my two
All-Americans of Kipnis and Leake carry my team to Omaha despite losing
our dominant 2nd starter Josh Spence for possibly the remainder of the
I have my doubts. But never say never.
Rex (Lodi): If UCLA takes two of three from
Fullerton and two of three from ASU and then wins its two midweek games
against the Dirtbags and Irvine do they have a shot at getting an at
A slim shot. That would make the Bruins
30-26 overall, but they'd still be on the bubble in the RPI (which is
currently 85th). According to Boyd's World, the Bruins need to go 7-1
down the stretch to finish with an RPI around 45, which is bubble
territory. I think UCLA basically has to win out. If the Bruins do
that, I think they sneak in based on their strength of schedule and
Brad (Chicago, IL): Is the Big Ten looking
like a three-bid league still? OSU took 2 of 3 from Illinois this
weekend, and Minnesota is one-half game ahead of the two of them for
the Big Ten lead right now. If one of them wins the conference
tournament, do all three get in to regionals?
It's definitely at least a two-bid league,
and I still think it'll probably wind up a three-bid league. If
Illinois wins the conference tournament, I think Minnesota definitely
gets in and Ohio State probably does. If Minnesota or OSU wins the
automatic bid, Illinois is very much on the bubble, but I think it
probably gets in. If Indiana wins the conference tournament (which
could very well happen), one of those other three teams is probably
going to get left out.
David (San Diego): How many teams from the WCC
get into the regionals. Does USD make it in? Also, do you think San
Diego State will make a regional?
One WCC team, though if LMU gets the
automatic bid, Gonzaga deserves an at-large (but might not get it). I
think San Diego's done.
ASU fan (Flagstaff, AZ): All I hear about
Kipnis is how hard he is to profile as a major leaguer. The kid may not
be a 'prospect tools' guy but he is a straight up ballplayer when it
comes down to it. I've also heard he can play 2B. Where do you see him
going in the draft come June and what position will he play his major
league career at; CF, LF, 2B? Thanks!
I see him as a mid-second rounder. It
seems like he'll probably get a shot at second base in pro ball, and if
he can handle it, he's got a real chance. But he's a tweener as an
outfielder. There have been thousands of great college players who are
straight-up ballplayers and gamers that haven't made the big leagues.
I'm not saying Kipnis won't, but the simple truth is he is a tricky one
to profile. That does not take away from the fact that he's a hell of a
player at the college level, and he's got a real chance at the next
Kyle (San Antonio): With a mid week win over
Rice and a sweep this weekend to claim the regular season Southland
crown, has Texas State secured a spot in the tournament?
Without question. Texas State was the
hardest team to leave out of the rankings this week — we had the
Bobcats as team No. 26 this week. That's a wonderful season, and Texas
State has earned itself a security blanket in case it fails to win the
Jim (Des Moines, Iowa): What is you take on
the Missouri Tigers? I see they are number 25, Do you think they can be
a legit super regional team. When you have a stud like gibson on friday
night, and tepesch who as flashed signs of brilliance, and an offense
that is on fire right now!
The Tigers are finally showing glimpses of
why they were so highly regarded in the preseason, when we had them
(admittedly over-ranked) at No. 10. I still have plenty of questions
about the pitching staff and the offense, but they're playing well at
the right time, and at least the staff is deep enough to give them
plenty of options. They really need the Dr. Jekyll Tepesch to show up
in the postseason, though.
Dan (Fairfield, CA): Why doesn't Tim Wheeler
(1.267 OPS, 14 SB in 16 attempts)ever get mentioned in top half of the
first round discussions? Especially in a year where there are so few
position player prospects at the college and prep levels. Is it
strictly because of the relatively weak competition that the Hornets
I think he's right there in that
discussion, actually. He's one of the best athletes out there, and he's
performed. I think he's got a real chance to go in the top 15, though I
don't speak for all of our draft writers, each of whom have their own
Jason (St. Louis): If Eastern Illinois, out of
the Ohio Valley Conference, ends up with 40 wins and falls short in
their conference tournament...Could you see them receiving an at-large
Yes, I think they're in pretty good shape, as long as they don't fall flat on their faces in the conference tourney.
Seth Wise (McDonough, GA): Given that Georgia
Tech took 2 out of 3 from Florida State this weekend, what do you think
the chances of Tech getting a top 8 seed in the NCAA tournament?
Chris (Louisville): How in the world is
Western Kentucky not in the top 25. The Sunbelt is sending at least two
teams to the regionals. They are 37-13 with a great RPI?
WKU was team No. 27 for me this week. I
really believe in that team's talent and believe it is a real threat to
win a regional. It will be a dangerous No. 2 seed in regionals. But the
0-0 record vs. top 25 teams kept the Hilltoppers out of the rankings
this week — we opted for Missouri, the No. 2 team in one of the
nation's best conferences (the Big 12).
John B (Arlington, VA): ECU has been pitching
really well as of late and their offense has been pretty dominant all
year. I know UNC is a regional host lock and UVA is up there too, but
Coastal has fallen lately (9-9 over last 18 games) and Clemson is
lingering. Assuming the Pirates have a 4-0 or 3-1 week so finish out
the regular season, where do they stand hosting a regional? GO PIRATES!
I'd say ECU is in the mix if Clemson and
Virginia both falter. Coastal's out of the discussion for me. I suppose
it's also possible that ECU, UNC and either Clemson OR Virginia could
host, especially if the Pirates make a deep CUSA tournament run.
JAYPERS (IL): Approximately which round does Robert Stock fit into at this point?
Around the third round, as a pitcher, of course.
Ron (DC): Pretty clear top eight at this point, right? UC-Irvine, Arizona State, Texas, LSU, Cal State Fullerton, Rice, UNC, GaTech.
Looks about right, but I still think
there's a chance one of those West Coast teams could be hosed by
geography. With only three likely sites out West, will the committee
really make all three national seeds, meaning all three would have to
face teams from other regions in super regionals? Given the current
economic climate and the committee's stated commitment to reducing
travel costs, that seems unlikely. But all three certainly deserve it
at this point, which complicates things, of course.
Paul (Richmond,Va): Went to UVA DUKE on friday
night and watched Hultzan pitch against Manno. Can you tell me where
Manno is on the list for this years Draft. He was lights out against my
Cavs and this is by far our best lineup in years. To be honest I was
I've heard some buzz on Manno lately —
his fastball command, plus changeup and competitiveness make up for his
lack of physicality. Don't be shocked if he sneaks up into the top
three or four rounds, though 5-7 might be a safer bet.
Gabe (boxford,mass): My friend can you tell me who in the acc will make the NCAA. Is Duke,BC VT in the running
I still think BC has a shot, though its
position is precarious. Duke and Virginia Tech are out — the Devils
had a chance to make a run before blowing a 9-3 lead late Saturday
against Virginia. That was a killer.
Maddog (Ashburn, VA): Aaron: Does Georgia
playing their way out of hosting a regional and Miami's recent
struggles help Clemson's chances in hosting? Or will it still,
ultimately, come down to UVA versus Clemson for a regional as you
Still think it comes down to Clemson v.
UVa., although having Miami out of the picture certainly helps. Now
it's down to a two-team race, unless of course the Hurricanes run
through the ACC tourney. I don't think Georgia has any bearing on it —
Georgia's hosting slot will just get shifted to another SEC team like
Tim (Long Beach): How many bids do you apiece
do the Pac-10 and Big West get? If it came down to a UC Riverside or
UCSB vs. UCLA, who gets that bid?
I don't think any of those three will be
in regionals. The Big West looks locked in as a three-bid league.
Amazingly, the Pac-10 has just one lock (Arizona State) right now,
though it still has a chance to get two others (Oregon State and
Washington State). Or I suppose Stanford could play its way in, but it
basically has to win out. Two or three is most likely. OK folks, that's
it for today — thanks for all the great questions, as usual. See you