| Q: | Aaron from Boston asks: Why was Josh Reddick rank so low? he had a really good season and he has a lot talent. |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Reddick in many ways was a surprise, so I believe some managers and scouts had a hard time believing how well he produced. He'll have to continue to prove himself, but he made a very strong first impression in the professional ranks. I believe he has a strong future. |
| Q: | Jason from Charlotte asks: What type of pitcher do you see Tommy Hanson as ?? I was surprised to see him so low on the list .. Is his ceiling not as high as other pitchers ? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Hanson is a guy who gets by with his great command and his ability to throw four pitches for strikes. What he doesn't have is an overpowering pitch, which causes some people to overlook him. I know the Braves are very high on him, and he made a seamless move to the Carolina League. He has the overall package to be a starter in the big leagues. |
| Q: | Bob from Saginaw, MI asks: Bill, How close was Clayton Tanner to making the list and can you tell us more about his stuff and projection. Thank you |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Tanner narrowly missed the list. Aside from Sosa, he received the most positive attention of any Augusta pitcher. He has outstanding command and is not afraid to challenge hitters. At the same time, he is not overpowering in any aspect of his repertoire, which leaves some observers wondering how he will fare at higher levels. Still, I believe he could reach the big leagues. |
| Q: | Jason from Charlotte asks: Jordan Schafer really had a breakout season. Would he have been #1 on the list if he had spent more time in the league ??? How long before we see him in center field for the Braves ? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: He might have if he had put up the same kind of numbers. I had several scouts last year who questioned if Schafer would ever hit enough to be a legit big leaguer. He went a long way toward answering that question this year. He is an incredible center fielder. If he has the same kind of season in 2008 that he had this past season, he could be in Atlanta's outfield in 2009. |
| Q: | Sam from Dallas, TX asks: Bill, Can Chris Carter replace Konerko or become a DH to replace Thome ? Thanks |
| A: | Bill Ballew: I think so. Carter's game is based on offense. He hits for power and average. No other aspect of his game will blow scouts away, but he who hits plays in the major leagues. |
| Q: | Steve from Owltown asks: What's the prognosis for Wade Townsend? Was he getting better command and velocity as the season progressed? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Townsend was making solid progress prior to missing the last portion of the season. He had a great April and then experienced some of the woes associated with injury comebacks. The Rays were encouraged with what they saw and believe he has a chance to put together a season in which he makes considerable progress along the organizational ladder in 2008. |
| Q: | Billy Joe from Macon, GA asks: Bill, Where would have Cole Rohrbough come in if he would have qualified ? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: That's hard to say since most managers did not see him, but based on those that did as well as the comments of Appy League managers and scouts, Rohrbough could have been a top 10 guy. The lefthander has quality stuff with great command, especially since he became more consistent with throwing the ball over the top instead of dropping down. Considering he had success after signing in May as a draft-and-follow pick, Rohrbough's future looks bright indeed. |
| Q: | Emmett from Fayetteville, GA asks: Was there any discussion about Jon Mark Owings and Tyler Flowers? Is Flowers someone you think could stay behind the plate? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Owings didn't get much, although I am a fan of his game. He needs to stay healthy so he can put together some consistency. He didn't have a bad year, but it was marred somewhat by ailments once again. I like Flowers more than many people. I think he has a very good bat. He split his time between first base and catcher, and he has considerable work to do if he wants to remain behind the plate for the long haul. |
| Q: | Patrick from Milwaukee, WI asks: The most notable omission on the list from what I can tell is Jeremy Jeffress. I know he has a hard time throwing strikes at times, but it's hard to argue with his athletic frame and delivery that produces his mid-90s heater and improving breaking ball. Did he not qualify given his 50-game suspension of baseball's substance abuse policy? As a league that was questioned for its star-power, it's somewhat surprising not seeing Jeffress make this list. |
| A: | Bill Ballew: The 50-game suspension did not help his cause, but he would not have received enough recognition without it. The attributes you list are accurate, but he did not impress managers with his lack of feel for his pitches. He's definitely a thrower instead of a pitcher at this point, but that can be said of a lot of other hurlers in the league. |
| Q: | Steven Alengakis from NYC asks: Which Yankees prospects got the most consideration -- if any for the top SAL prospect list? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Mitch Hilligoss receieved some love, although he doesn't always look pretty doing his job. Austin Jackson showed some athletic ability and tools, but he still needs to figure it out. On the mound, Robertson came out of nowhere as a reliever with his 91-92 mph cut fastball. |
| Q: | John C from Acworth, GA asks: Thanks for taking my question. As a long suffering Orioles fan, I was wondering if you could tell me what managers and scouts thought of Pedro Beato. Thank you. |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Beato is a righthander with four pitches who throws 90-94 mph. He has a good feel for his changeup and his cutter was good early in the year. He did not have a great season, but he has the ability to be a major league pitcher. |
| Q: | Patrick from Milwaukee, WI asks: Did Zach Braddock earn any love from the managers and scouts across the league, as he was untouchable through 47 innings before being shut down in June? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: In a league as big as the 16-team SAL, it's easy for a player to get overlooked. I think that's what happened with Braddock. He was lights out when I saw him earlier in the season. |
| Q: | Herbie from Staten Island asks: Were any of the following Yankee prospects close to making the cut? Position players Josue Calzado, Mitch Hilligoss and Kyle Anson and Pitchers Ivan Nova, Michael Dunn, David Robertson and Ferdin Tejeda? Any of them worth keeping an eye on? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: I mentioned David Robertson a few responses ago; he was one of manager Torre Tyson's top picks among Charleston players with big league futures. Dunn is another guy who came out of nowhere. A former first baseman, the lefthander has two plus pitches, a cutter and slider, and sits in th 90-91 mph range. Calzado has tools off the charts, including one of the league's strongest arms this year. He also made a steady climb up the batting order as he got more comfortable getting professional ABs. He's another guy worth keeping an eye on. |
| Q: | Grant from Fresno, CA asks: Hi Bill, thanks for the chat. How does Henry Sosa profile? What is his ceiling, and how likely is it for him to get there? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Sosa was mentioned by every manager that saw him. He has a great fastball and an even better breaking ball. He's still learning how to pitch in certain situations, but he can throw in the mid-90s and then attack with the hook. If he can refine the raw tools he possesses, he can be a No. 2 or 3 starter in the big leagues. |
| Q: | Pitak from CT asks: Zero Mets in the top 20? Just how bad is their farm system and why? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: I'm not as qualified to talk about the rest of the Mets' organization, but the Savannah team was woefully short on prospects. Without question, they were the league's weakest team. |
| Q: | jason from st louis asks: what is sosas ceiling?? is he a potential number 1-2, or a middle rotation guy? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: It's all according to how he refines his tools and learns how to pace himself. If that happens, he could be a top starter. |
| Q: | T. Epstein from Boston asks: Bill, thanks for the chat. What type of ceiling do you see Lars Anderson having? In your opinion will he more of a solid big league regular or potential All-Star? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Anderson could be an all-star. He makes very consistent contact and he's learning how to drive the ball. He has a knack for putting solid wood on most pitches he hits. His defense is also pretty darn good. He's a legit top prospect. |
| Q: | Phil from Overland Park, KS asks: Where would Pedro Beato rank? Do you still see a lot of potential in him? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Beato was a near-miss on the list. In July, I thought he would be a shoo-in, but he did not pitch that well over the course of the season. Remember, the SAL is a 16-team league, and Beato has the raw tools to be a success on the bump if he can refine his skills. |
| Q: | James from Charlotte asks: No Keith weiser?? He dominated hitters all year. What's his long term ceiling? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Weiser led the league in wins with his tremendous feel for pitching. He was a little bit of an older, more experienced guy who knew how to get younger batters out. What impressed me was how he had so much success despite pitching his home games in the bandbox that is McCormick Field. Unfortunately, nothing in his repertoire or overall tools package is particularly impressive. I guess all he does is win! |
| Q: | JAYPERS from IL asks: Very pleased to see the athleticism of Jennings get recognized. I know how slowly TB's management is to promote their prospects, though. That being said, how quickly can he go through their system, assuming he stays healthy? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Jennings is still developing and is most likely three years from reaching the big leagues. He has great tools and he put many things together this year. At the same time, he's still learning how to be a better defensive center fielder as well as how to incorporate his speed to the best of his ability. |
| Q: | Todd from bristol, va asks: After watching a Greensboro Grasshopper game this past year, I was super impressed with John Raynor. How much did it hurt him compared to the other outfielders on the list that he went to college? He reminds me of a poor mans Grady Sizemore with good power in the leadoff spot. Where do you think he will land on the Marlins list in next years handbook? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: I have been a big John Raynor fan since he was at UNC Wilmington. I've had several observers disagree with me, but I think he more than showed what he is capable of accomplishing this past year. He reminds me of John Cangelosi. I don't know where he will rank on the Marlins' list, but I wouldn't count him out regardless of his placement. |
| Q: | jason from hazelwood asks: can you compare hector gomez to a current major leaguer? and why that comparison? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: With his fielding, he reminds me somewhat of Davey Concepcion. He's tall with very fluid motions. At the plate, he has a little Vladimir Guerrero in him in that he's a free swinger who is capable of hitting virtually any pitch. As the total package, I had more than one scout compare him to Miguel Tejada. |
| Q: | JAYPERS from IL asks: No Burriss? He's SF's SS of the future, is he not? What kept him off? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Burriss was brutal in the California League, and as a college guy in the South Atlantic League, he had success against younger competition. He has impressive speed and is generally considered above-average defensively at shortstop, but his bat and swing need to close some pretty significant holes before he has his heart set on AT&T Park. |
| Q: | Mike from Harrisburg, PA asks: Any support for CF Matt McBride? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: There was. McBride can absolutely fly and he is a major league caliber center fielder. He's still learning how to use the bat in the professional ranks, but I believe he has a strong future. He could be on the same path as Jordan Schafer, who opened this past season at Rome before earning a promotion to high A Myrtle Beach in May. |
| Q: | JAYPERS from IL asks: One of the lone bright spots in the Sox organization is John Shelby. He played a good season, yet missed the list. Comments? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Shelby really turned the corner this year. He got tired at midseason before finishing fairly strong. Shelby has great hands and is able to use the entire field. While he does a good job of putting the ball in play, Shelby needs to focus on using the middle of the field in order to put his above-average speed to better use. |
| Q: | JAYPERS from IL asks: A good TB pitcher who seems to be in Hellickson's shadow is Heath Rollins, who had an even better season. Why did he miss out? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Rollins is still learning how to pitch. There is no denying his arm strength, and he did get some consideration from several managers. But being an older guy and not being as polished as several others led to his missing the list. |
| Q: | Phil from Overland Park, KS asks: Where does Hellickson fit in the future D-Rays rotation? How fast do you see him progressing? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: The Rays have no interest in pushing Hellickson. He had a very impressive season and really made a lot of progress with his knowledge of the pitching craft. His strength is his electric stuff and great arm action. He also commands the fastball very well. Every comparison to Hellickson included Greg Maddux, which is pretty darn good company. |
| Q: | Ron Brown from Las Vegas , Nv asks: Although Chris Carter was number 10 I thought he would have been higher. With that said what do you think of his numbers this year and were do you see him playing next year. Also do you see him in the majors anytime soon. Thanks |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Carter obviously had good numbers. He's a young guy who works hard and is very mature for his age. His raw power is unquestioned. His defense is a work in progress, so that might keep him on a one-level-per-year pace for the immediate future. |
| Q: | Tony Farlow from Asheville, NC asks: Being a big Tourists fan I spent a lot of time at McCormick Field this season (my wife always appreciates that). I truly enjoyed the double play tandem of Hector Gomez and Daniel Mayora, what do you think will become of these two? Considering the Rockies depth of Shortstop prospects and the talk of Ian Stewart playing some second base in Arizona this fall. |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Gomez and Sosa probably received the most mentions of any players in the league. Gomez oozes tools, and combined with his obvious love for the game, he produces big responses. Mayora surprised the Rockies with his output. Mayora is a former shortstop with excellent defensive skills. His bat was extremely productive, but some consideration needs to be taken into his home field, McCormick Field. Gomez has the higher ceiling, but Mayora could be a second baseman or a pretty decent utility man at higher levels. |
| Q: | Henry Thompson from Tiburon CA asks: Was Billy Rowell ranked so low due to defensive value potenital or performance because he was adequate and playing against players more advanced them him. Because of his huge potential why didn't he rank higher? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Rowell went through a tremendous learning experience this year that might have overshadowed his efforts in the eyes of onlookers. He struggled against lefthanders and off-speed pitches and has plenty of holes in his swing. That said, he has a good eye at the plate and is at least capable of becoming a solid defensive third baseman. True, he was 18, but Rowell simply has more to work on before he'll rank among the league's top prospects. |
| Q: | Brian from Alexandria asks: What are your thoughts on SunsP-Nats OF Mike Daniel? He doesn't seem to be a premium prospect but could he develop into a #4 OF? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Daniel looks like a guy who will develop more power as his body matures. He can play all three outfield positions and runs down balls throughout the garden. He's also a high average hitter. I think you're right on the money in that he isn't a top prospect, but he's definitely an above-average player who could be a productive fourth outfielder if he continues to develop. |
| Q: | Evan from Miami asks: Florida 1B Logan Morrison (Greensboro) had a big year- how close was he to cracking the top 20 and what kept him off the list? Thanks. |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Morrison turned 20 in August and showed tremendous improvement over the course of the season. His manager, Edwin Rodriguez, believes Morrison could be a guy who hits 30-35 home runs a season. His work habits are excellent, which should make him at least an average first baseman. Still, his raw power will keep him moving through the organization, particuarly with his ability to drive the ball to the opposite field. |
| Q: | D. Cornell from Madison, WI asks: Jon Mark Owings...Prospect or Suspect? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Right now he's more suspect than prospect. He has the package of tools, but his performance and inability to stay healthy have hurt his chances. |
| Q: | Pryce from Atlanta asks: Bill, Happy to see Hanson and Schafer make your list. After the Teixeira trade it seems the system's a little light on talent. Moving forward do you see Hanson or Rohrbough having a higher ceiling? Braves fans have heard great things about both. Who would you rather have? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: That's a tough one, simply because Hanson has been through a full season and Rohrbough has not. Rohrough probably would be the choice among scouts, but I don't think you could go wrong with either one. |
| Q: | cjb from madison, wi asks: How close to you is the MilledgeJennings comparison? With Jennings being a bit taller does he project to have more power? How far aways is Jennings to being big league ready? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: Jennings is still a few years away from the big leagues. From a tools standpoint those are valid comparisons with Milledge, but Jennings has a huge edge in terms of makeup. |
| Q: | Todd from Chattanooga asks: With the potential of Andruw Jones leaving Atlanta next year via free agency, can you see Jordan Schafer having a realistic shot to reach Atlanta sooner than later? |
| A: | Bill Ballew: I believe Schafer is at least a year away from the big leagues. I also think Andruw Jones will not be re-signed. One option the Braves are considering is moving Jeff Francoeur to center field until Schafer is ready. |
Moderator: Thanks for the chat, guys. Lots of great questions. Take care.