League Top 20 Prospects

Midwest League Top 20 Prospects Chat




 Q:  Mike Marinaro from Tampa, FL asks:
Is kershaw the best lefty prospect since Cole Hamels? How does Jacob McGee compare to Kershaw?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Kershaw is a better prospect than Hamels was, because he has more stuff and a much better medical history. He's the best in a while. McGee would be the No. 2 lefty in the minors behind Kershaw. They're close, but I like Kershaw's breaking ball better and he's more advanced than McGee was at the same age.

 Q:  Gerry from Toronto asks:
Did any Lansing pitcher get any consideration, I thought Kyle Ginley might have had a chance, his numbers were good and he is still young.
 A: 

Jim Callis: Not for the Top 20 . . . Lansing didn't have anyone who was close except for Travis Snider, who checked in at No. 2. Ginley has a good fastball, probably will be a reliever in the long run if he makes it.

 Q:  Jerred Gracey from York, Pa asks:
Were there any Cardinals who didn't make the list to get excited about?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Reliever Kenny Maiques really interests me, as a guy with a tough fastball-slider combo. I think he can help the Cardinals in the next couple of years, and he was one of the guys who just missed making the list. Brandon Buckman and Steven Hill had good offensive years but both were quite old for the MWL and I want to see them at higher levels. There were some more good pitches on Quad City, such as Brad Furnish, P.J. Walters and Eddie Degerman.

 Q:  Greg from Toronto asks:
How close was Travis Snider from overtaking Kershaw for the top spot? I've noticed that Snider's pilled up alot of K. Is this a cause for concern and something that he can improve upon?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Not very close, as Kershaw was clearly the consensus choice of MWL observers. He was the clear No. 1, Snider was the clear No. 2, and then the league started to drop off. I wouldn't worry too much about the strikeouts. Snider is young and he was in perhaps the toughest hitter's league in full-season ball. He walks enough, and he'll produce plenty even if he racks up some strikeouts.

 Q:  Phil from Overland Park, KS asks:
No Jermaine Mitchell on this list, can you give us a guess of where he would've landed? Does Jermaine project as an everday player in the big leagues in your opinion?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Mitchell would have been in the 31-50 range somewhere (for the first time of perhaps many, I'll point out that the MWL has 14 teams, so it's list runs deeper than most, even in a so-so year for talent). Mitchell is a good athlete and he's not just a slap-and-run guy, but the scouts weren't in love with his bat and saw him as more of a fourth outfielder.

 Q:  D. Cornell from Madison, WI asks:
What's your take on P.J. Phillips? He was a MWL All-Star and he's still pretty young. Does he have Brandon's skills?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Phillips has a lot of a raw ability, with the emphasis on "raw." He's not as polished as Brandon was at the same stage. P.J. still needs to make a lot more contact and get a lot more consistent on the defensive side.

 Q:  Warren from Texas asks:
I am curious about some of the Whitecaps that did not make the list. Boesch, Sizemore, and Strieby all had positive writeups in college, another league, or the draft preview, but none made it. How close were they and what did your contacts have to say about them, if anything? Thanks for the chat!
 A: 

Jim Callis: Remember that all of those guys were old for the league, too. West Michigan is a tough place to hit, but none of them had even an .800 OPS and Boesch couldn't crack .700. Sizemore has the best chance to reach the majors, more as a utility guy. The position player who got the most mention on that club was catcher James Skelton, but he's also undersized.

 Q:  Phillip from Overland Park, KS asks:
Does Trevor Cahill project as a front or back of the rotation starter?
 A: 

Jim Callis: More middle, a No. 3 or 4. He doesn't have the pure stuff nor the projection to envision him as a frontline guy. That said, he's very polished for his age and perhaps the best pitching prospect in the A's system.

 Q:  Phil from Op, KS asks:
Where does Conger rank in your mind on the total list of catchers in the minor leagues?
 A: 

Jim Callis: He has more upside than most, especially with the bat. The big question is whether he can stay behind the plate. He's missed a lot of time with injuries, costing him some needed experiences, and scouts aren't sold on his throwing or receiving.

 Q:  Sean from MA asks:
Is the Cedar Rapids team the most talented in MWL? It seems that they have a legitimate propect in every position. Is there anyone else who received consideration for top 20?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Yes, the Kernels were the most prospect-laden club in the league. 3B Matt Sweeney just missed the Top 20, and OF Chris Pettit (though older) had a good deal of support. Among their other standouts were OF Peter Bourjos and RHPs Trevor Bell and Warner Madrigal. LHP Barret Browning could get to L.A. pretty quick as a reliever. We already discussed Phillips, and 2B Ryan Mount is another talented infielder. The club was loaded with athletes and quality arms.

 Q:  walter from Plano, Texas asks:
What do you see from Chris Parmalee moving forward. He was in your top 100 last year and seemed to struggle greatly. Will he repeat the league or is it best he move on to a more hitter friendly league? Thanks...
 A: 

Jim Callis: He did struggle, though keep in mind that he was 19 and it's a tough hitter's league. Scouts weren't in love with his bat, as one questioned whether he could hit even a fringy fastball and another pointed out that he constantly changed his swing and approach. Not sure what the Twins will do, but they've typically moved guys on, which could help get Parmelee's bat going in a hitter-friendlier league.

 Q:  Andy from Iowa City asks:
Cards fans have been told that Daryl Jones is a potential 5-tool player, but we are stil waiting for him to produce. I watched him play a few times this year and he looks better than in 2006. He seems to have the athleticism, but he occasionally has some lackadaisical at-bats. What do scouts think of him at this point?
 A: 

Jim Callis: He has a lot of tools but still looks lost at the plate. He's still young at 20 but has so far to go. Guys are cooling on him.

 Q:  John from ocala, fl asks:
Can you tell me if Derrick Robinson had any consideration for this list? I know coming out of high school, he was considered a premier athlete that had a ways to go with baseball. I saw where he finished the year in high-A and he seemed to hold his own fairly well for a raw teenager competing against some pretty advanced competition.
 A: 

Jim Callis: Everyone is considered . . . we do a thorough job of asking about everyone. But no one was high on any prospect on Burlington. Robinson is a tremendous athleterunner, but he hits a lot of harmless groundballs. I don't like his bat at all, and I didn't talk to anyone who did.

 Q:  Brett from IL asks:
I know that Matt Sulentic was overmatched this year in the MWL, but what do you see for his future and do you see him rebounding in his second chance next year?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Sulentic was one of the biggest disappointments for me this year. Got off to a horrible start in the MWL and couldn't or wouldn't make adjustments. He was way off balance at the plate and couldn't make hard contact. After a demotion to the Northwest League, he was better but struck out a ton. There's some hitting ability in there, but it sure didn't come out in 2007. Next year will be crucial for him.

 Q:  Bob from Seattle, WA asks:
Jim, thanks for the chat. How would you compare Travis Snider's year in the MWL, as a 19-year old, with last years 19-year old OF's (Upton, Bruce, Maybin, et al)? How does he compare with those 2005 HS picks as well as McCutcheon and Rasmus?
 A: 

Jim Callis: In terms of prospectness, to make up a word, Snider would rank behind Upton, Bruce, Maybin and Rasmus from last year's MWL crop. All have tons of hitting ability as well and can do a lot more on the bases and in the outfield than Snider can. I'd rank Snider ahead of McCutchen, though, after the year McCutchen had with the bat.

 Q:  Richard from Ft. Lauderdale asks:
In regards to Alessandro Maestri and Alex Liddi, is there a chance that we could see Italians playing major league baseball?
 A: 

Jim Callis: There's a chance, but it's a ways off. Maestri is fringy and Liddi has some potential but a long way to develop physically and as a baseball player.

 Q:  JAYPERS from IL asks:
Could AZ bring up Anderson at some point next year, if he maintains his numbers? Or does his need to improve his athleticism act as a stumbling block?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Might be a little quick for Brett Anderson, but he's on the fast track. He's a lefty who can really locate three pitches. His lack of athleticism hasn't caught up to him yet and it shouldn't prevent him from succeeding, though I would think MLB teams might be able to exploit him with bunts more than minor league clubs could. He really needs to get into better shape.

 Q:  Ben from Leland Grove asks:
Was Duane Below considered for the list, and what kept him off?
 A: 

Jim Callis: He wasn't real close to making it. Nice year at West Michigan, but he's an older guy in a pitcher's park, and he can command multiple pitches. Those guys usually do very well in low Class A.

 Q:  Deywane from Memphis asks:
What kept Sean Watson off this list? He was pretty dominant in the MWL and I heard his stuff was pretty good.
 A: 

Jim Callis: He was close to making it. Ultimately, it came down to me thinking he would be a reliever and putting him behind guys I believed in more as starters: Sean O'Sullivan, Trevor Cahill and Tyler Robertson. I do like Watson's fastball-slider combo, and in a league with less than 14 teams, he would have made it.

 Q:  Doug from Chicago asks:
My question is about Josh Bell and Preston Mattingly. Do you think Bell has the skill level to be a MLB 3B? If so, can you project his stats. What happened to Mattingly? Highly thought of and drafted high. I expected greater things because of blood lines and talent.
 A: 

Jim Callis: Bell has the tools to be a third baseman, but scouts say he'll need to take his defense more seriously and work at it. I could see him as a .270 hitter with 25-plus homers in the majors. Mattingly had a dreadful year. He was an enigma in the 2006 draft, as some clubs really liked him and others weren't on him much. He's not a good defender and probably will wind up in LF, and he's still very raw at the plate. That may be surprising because of the bloodlines, but he was a three-sport star and doesn't have as much baseball experience as you might expect.

 Q:  Robert Goldberg from Lyndhurst, NJ asks:
Jim - what kind of ceiling does Kasey Kiker have as a starter? I know that most feel he's going to end up in the bullpen due to his size, etc, but didn't a lot of scouts feel the same way about Kazmir?
 A: 

Jim Callis: The biggest difference between those two is that Kazmir had more polish and command at the same stage. Also, his velo didn't dip as much in his first full season as it did with Kiker.

 Q:  Dawson from California asks:
Why Matthew Sweeney didn't make the list? he had a solid year. If Hank Conger can't stay behind the plate where do you project him to play? would his power play there?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Sweeney was very close to making the list. What worked against him is that I only had 20 spots for players on 15 teams, and scouts don't give him any chance to play third base in the majors. He's a first baseman, and that hurt him in comparison to guys like Josh Bell, Johnny Whittleman and Juan Francisco. Conger would play first base and could have enough bat to play there--his bat is that good.

 Q:  Tim from Proctorville, Ohio asks:
Sean O'Sullivan has incredible success but seems to lack an out pitch. Is that going to catch up to him at higher levels or even relegate him to the bullpen at some point?
 A: 

Jim Callis: That's an accurate assessment of his stuff. It often does catch up to guys at higher levels, though Sullivan's feel for pitching is so outstanding that he may be an exception. While he's interesting, he's far from a slam-dunk guy.

 Q:  cjb from madison, wi asks:
5 years from now who is more dominate....clayton kershaw or felix hernandez?
 A: 

Jim Callis: I'll still take Felix.

 Q:  Pedro Lopez from Boston asks:
Does Carlos Triunfel has the the power to play 3B? of the two SS signed as international free agent in 06 that made there American debut this year, Oscar Tejeda and Carlos Triunfel, who has the better chance to stay at SS? and who has the better power potential and overall offensive Package?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Triunfel does project to hit enough to play third base, which is good news, because the scouts I talked to say he's destined to move there. He lacks the range, speed and athleticism for shortstop. Boston's Oscar Tejeda is a legit shortstop, but Triunfel has shown more with the bat to this point.

 Q:  Tom from St. Louis asks:
How close was Clayton Mortensen to making the list? Was he eligible? What kind of stuff did he show while in the midwest league?
 A: 

Jim Callis: He didn't pitch enough innings to qualify. As a starter, he needed 13 IP for each team game. Same thing happened to him in the New York-Penn League as well. Mortensen has a plus sinker and an intriguing slider.

 Q:  Erik from Wisconsin asks:
Based on what the Twins have said, it sounds as if they are very high on Wilson Ramos. He isn't a big guy, but did hit for some solid power this year in the MWL. Is he adequate both offensively and defensively to be considered a legit prospect within the Twins system? Or did Drew Butera take that spot over when he was acquired? :)
 A: 

Jim Callis: They are high on Ramos, and he's another guy who just missed the list. Most scouts liked him more than Parmelee or Benson, and he was easily the best all-around catcher in the league. Hank Conger was a better hitter and Wellington Castillo (Peoria) might have been a better defender, but neither had Ramos' all-around game.

 Q:  Bill Dictus from Madison, Wis. asks:
Wow, no Cedric Hunter...#1 prospect in a league last year and not even in the top 20 this year. What are scouts saying about him?
 A: 

Jim Callis: They were disappointed. Thought he needed to show a lot more energy and effort, and that he was off balance at the plate with a really loopy swing that would make it hard to generate any power.

 Q:  Eric from San Diego asks:
Where would Kershaw have ranked if he was on last year's list?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Probably fourth. I would have taken elite bats like Bruce, Maybin and Upton ahead of him.

 Q:  Joe from Grand Rapids asks:
Did Charlie Furbush generate any buzz during his short time in the league? Any thoughts on the future of B. Jensen?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Furbush was pretty good, but he didn't qualify and I'm still not completely sold on him after a so-so spring at LSU. I do like Brett Jensen, a very effective sidearmer. I'm always surprised there aren't more of those guys in the majors.

 Q:  NEC from White Plains, NY asks:
If Gorkys Hernandez were to make a strong push in the near future for a call-up, where would he fit in with Maybin and Granderson, Magglio? Who would be the more effective leadoff hitter - Granderson or Gorkys? Could we potentially see all 3 of these prospects in the same OF?
 A: 

Jim Callis: He doesn't have the same impact bat those other guys do. Hernandez is a more traditional style of leadoff hitter than Granderson, but it's hard to argue with the season Granderson has had. I do think Granderson-Hernandez-Maybin will be Detroit's outfield of the future.

 Q:  Bill Dictus from Madison, Wis. asks:
Has Tony Butler's ultimate ceiling been affected by this season?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Not really. He got off to a bad start, got hurt, then finished strong. I did have a scout who said his arm action caused him to worry about his control and durability. But Butler is still a big lefty with quality stuff, so the ceiling is still high.

 Q:  Steve from Yellowstone asks:
What do you think led to Kasey Kiker's drop in velocity this season?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Not uncommon at all, especially for teenagers in their first full season. Very few amateurs have experience starting every fifth day, and it often takes a toll on their stuff.

 Q:  Ben from Leland Grove asks:
Who would you say has a higher ceiling at this point - Manship or Slowey?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Hmmm. For me, they have similar ceilings as good No. 3 starters. Neither has tremendous stuff, so I think you have to go to the guy who comes out best in command, the strong suit for both. That would be Slowey.

 Q:  Mark L. Peel from Arlington Heights, IL asks:
Jim, did MWL managers have anything to say about Peoria starter Robert Hernandez? On the face of things, he competed pretty well despite being very young for the league (18); but he looked a bit underwhelming in person.
 A: 

Jim Callis: That's an accurate assessment. He didn't light anyone up, but his age makes him a guy to keep an eye on for the future.

 Q:  Ben from Baltimore asks:
How do you feel about Steve Hill from Swing of the Quad Cities? Does he have a future as a catcher?
 A: 

Jim Callis: The power intrigues me. He's not really a catcher, though he has played there some during college and sparingly as a pro. He's much more of a guy who would be a backup first basemanoutfielder and a third catcher than he is a regular catcher.

 Q:  Craig from Avenel, NJ asks:
Jim, It sounds like all Drew Miller has to do is grow up a little bit because he has the stuff to be successful. Fair assessment ?
 A: 

Jim Callis: Very fair. At his best, he had as good a three-pitch combo as anyone in the league. But he was easily flustered and didn't dominate on a consistent basis.

 Q:  Lew from Raleigh asks:
Hernandez, Maybin, or Granderson will be the Tigers centerfielder when they all share an outfield in a few years?
 A: 

Jim Callis: I'll guess Hernandez but it will be a close call.

 Q:  John from Wheaton, IL asks:
How does Jose Ceda project, and when can he help the Cubs in a bullpen role? You have to like his line as a reliever this past season.
 A: 

Jim Callis: He's a possible closer. He has two power pitches in his fastball and his slider, but he has to really improve his changeup, mechanics and command to make it as a starter. He's still somewhat raw, so I wouldn't count on seeing him in Chicago before mid-2009.

 Q:  Tom B. from Cincinnati asks:
Hi Jim: How do you project Drew Stubbs? As a .250-hitter with 20+ power, or does he have it in him to hit for a higher average? Thanks!
 A: 

Jim Callis: Maybe .260 or .270. I don't think he'll ever hit for a high average, but Stubbs still can be a very good big leaguer, as a 20-20 or maybe 30-30 guy providing Gold Glove defense in center field.

 Q:  Erik from Wisconsin asks:
What's the story behind Robert Delaney? Is he your typical hard throwing closer? What kind of stuff does he possess? He finished the year in Ft. Myers but was with Beloit for the bulk of the season. He's got a big frame that looks projectable, but what does he offer?
 A: 

Jim Callis: No, he doesn't have the stuff to match his great numbers. He commands an average fastball very well, setting up hitters for his slider. Keep an eye on him, but he looks like a middle reliever at best. He also was 22, old for the MWL.

 Q:  Adam from NYC asks:
Is Johnny Whittleman for real, or does this season and his numbers make him look better than his ceiling projects?
 A: 

Jim Callis: He's a pretty interesting hitter, capable of hitting .280 with 15-20 homers in the majors if it all works out. Legit prospect, needs to get a lot better defensively at third base, though he does work at it.

Moderator: That's all for today. We'll resume our League Top 20 chats on Monday, with Bill Ballew and the South Atlantic League.