| CALIFORNIA LEAGUE | CAROLINA LEAGUE | FLORIDA STATE LEAGUE | |
| Best Batting Prospect | Bubba Bell, Lancaster | Chris Marrero, Potomac | Jay Bruce, Sarasota |
| Best Power Prospect | Chris Davis, Bakersfield | Wes Hodges, Kinston | Jay Bruce, Sarasota |
| Best Strike-Zone Judgment | Aaron Bates, Lancaster | Max Ramirez, Kinston | Mat Gamel, Brevard County |
| Best Baserunner | Eric Young Jr., Modesto | Josh Flores, Salem | Cameron Maybin, Lakeland |
| Fastest Baserunner | Eric Young Jr., Modesto | Pedro Powell, Lynchburg | Ovandy Suero, Lakeland |
| Best Pitching Prospect | Brandon Hynick, Modesto | Brad James, Salem | Joba Chamberlain, Tampa |
| Best Fastball | Pedro Strop, Modesto | Bob McCrory, Frederick | Jake McGee, Vero Beach |
| Best Breaking Ball | Jams McDonald, Inland Empire | Chorye Spoone, Frederick | Will Inman, Brevard County |
| Best Changeup | Wade Leblanc, Lake Elsinore | Julio Pimentel, Wilmington | Carlos Carrasco, Clearwater |
| Best Control | Brandon Hynick, Modesto | Rowdy Hardy, Wilmington | Daniel McCutchen, Tampa |
| Best Reliever | Daniel Stange, Visalia | Bob McCrory, Frederick | Josh Roenicke, Sarasota |
| Best Defensive Catcher | Neil Wilson, Modesto | Cole Armstrong, Winston-Salem | Lou Marson, Clearwater |
| Best Defensive First Baseman | Aaron Bates, Lancaster | Kala Kaaihue, Myrtle Beach | Rhyne Hughes, Vero Beach |
| Best Defensive Second Baseman | Matt Antonelli, Lake Elsinore | Shelby Ford, Lynchburg | Kevin Russo, Tampa |
| Best Defensive Third Baseman | David Freese, Lake Elsinore | Wes Hodges, Kinston | Michael Griffin, Sarasota |
| Best Defensive Shortstop | Brian Bocock, San Jose | Elvis Andrus, Myrtle Beach | Alcides Escobar, Brevard County |
| Best Infield Arm | Hainley Statia, Rancho Cucamonga | Ian Desmond, Potomac | Alcides Escobar, Brevard County |
| Best Defensive Outfielder | Dexter Fowler, Modesto | Jordan Schafer, Myrtle Beach | Greg Golson, Clearwater |
| Best Outfield Arm | Leyson Septimo, Visalia | Jordan Schafer, Myrtle Beach | Nate Southard, Palm Beach |
| Most Exciting Player | Eric Young Jr., Modesto | Elvis Andrus, Myrtle Beach | Cameron Maybin, Lakeland |
| Best Managerial Prospect | Dave Collins, Inland Empire | Mike Sarbaugh, Kinston | Luis Sojo, Tampa |
| MIDWEST LEAGUE | SOUTH ATLANTIC LEAGUE | |
| Best Batting Prospect | Gerardo Parra, South Bend | Chris Marrero, Hagerstown |
| Best Power Prospect | Juan Francisco, Dayton | Chris Carter, Kannapolis |
| Best Strike-Zone Judgment | John Whittleman, Clinton | Chris Coghlan, Greensboro |
| Best Baserunner | Matt Camp, Peoria | John Raynor, Greensboro |
| Fastest Baserunner | Gorkys Hernandez, West Michigan | John Raynor, Greensboro |
| Best Pitching Prospect | Clayton Kershaw, Great Lakes | Tommy Hanson, Rome |
| Best Fastball | Clayton Kershaw, Great Lakes | Henry Sosa, Augusta |
| Best Breaking Ball | Jeff Manship, Beloit | Wilfrido Perez, Delmarva |
| Best Changeup | Brett Anderson, South Bend | Josh Wilkie, Hagerstown |
| Best Control | Jeff Manship, Beloit | Kevin Pucetas, Augusta |
| Best Reliever | Robert Delaney, Beloit | Jonathan Hovis, Charleston |
| Best Defensive Catcher | Wellington Castillo, Peoria | Tuffy Gosewich, Lakewood |
| Best Defensive First Baseman | Brandon Buckman, Quad Cities | Lars Anderson, Greenville |
| Best Defensive Second Baseman | Scott Sizemore, West Michigan | Chris Coghlan, Greensboro |
| Best Defensive Third Baseman | Josh Lansford, Peoria | Jared Goedert, Lake County |
| Best Defensive Shortstop | Jesus Lopez, Fort Wayne | Hector Gomez, Asheville |
| Best Infield Arm | Jesus Lopez, Fort Wayne | Hector Gomez, Asheville |
| Best Defensive Outfielder | Drew Stubbs, Dayton | Desmond Jennings, Columbus |
| Best Outfield Arm | Gerardo Parra, South Bend | Jordan Parraz, Lexington |
| Most Exciting Player | Gorkys Hernandez, West Michigan | John Raynor, Greensboro |
| Best Managerial Prospect | Tom Brookens, West Michigan | Mike Guerrero, West Virginia |