Russell Promotion Continues Cubs’ Roster Transformation
Sure, theyÂ havenâ€™t won anything yet. But if you are looking at the most impressive rebuilding job of the past five years, what the Cubs have done deserves praise, and it […]
2005 Draft Scouting Reports: Puerto Rico
By John Manuel
(National ranking in parentheses)
1. IVAN DE JESUS (National rank: 108)
School: Puerto Rico Military Academy.
Hometown: Guaynabo, P.R.
B-T: R-R. Ht.: 5-11. Wt.: 175. Birthdate: May 1, 1987.
College Commitment: None.
Scouting Report: With a resume that includes a polished bat, a big league father and a lack of a strong college commitment, De Jesus could be drafted well and a bit higher than his talent might warrant. De Jesus’ father Ivan was a shortstop for the Cubs and Phillies in the 1970s and '80s but with a different type of game from his son. Where the father was a slasher and speed player, the son fits the modern game better with more power in his bat and average speed (4.3 seconds to first base). The current De Jesus model has a good idea at the plate, and his bat gets above-average grades from scouts in the 55-60 range (on the 20-80 scale), projecting him to be a .280-.300 hitter. Whether De Jesus hits for power will determine his ceiling. He has some present jolt in his swing due to strong wrists and forearms. Scouts are mixed on him defensively. He has good hands and instincts, and he could handle second base easily. Whether he has enough arm to consistently make the play in the hole will determine whether he plays shortstop in the big leagues like his father.
OTHERS TO WATCH
(Numbers in parentheses indicate rank in Puerto Rico)
While De Jesus is motivated to sign, the island’s No. 2 prospect, SS Hector Pellot (2), may not be. Pellot made several college visits, including one to Southern California, before committing to Santa Clara. He has a bit more speed and arm than De Jesus, meaning he’s more likely to stay at shortstop, but he’ll need to work on his hands. They’re a little stiff. Pellot needs work at the plate as well, where he lacks strength and can get the bat knocked out of his hands. A team that believes in his bat will take Pellot with a single-digit pick.
SS Eric Santiago (8) is a premium athlete with 6.5-second speed over 60 yards and a powerful arm (he throws in the high 80s off the mound). Santiago also is an excellent athlete who excels at basketball and volleyball, leaving him raw on the diamond, especially at the plate. He’s going to take two years in Rookie ball to iron out the kinks in his swing.
A pair of Puerto Rican catchers could be drafted in the first 10 rounds. Julio Rivera (5) has a modest arm but a feel at the plate, and is still improving after moving from third base. Carlos Rodriguez (3) is athletic with more arm strength, while lacking much of an approach at the plate.
The island’s pitching is as thin as LHP Orvil Aviles (10), who has a fringy fastball from his 6-foot-4 frame complemented by a good changeup and decent curveball. Area scouts didn’t seem to agree with the Major League Scouting Bureau’s assessment of Gabriel Fargas (4), who got a 65 overall grade (highest in Puerto Rico and among the highest in the 2005 draft class) on the 20-80 scouting scale. Garcia couldn’t throw strikes at the Excellence Games, and one scout said the converted outfielder, who topped out at 93 mph in a fall showcase, threw 27 straight pitches out of the strike zone. He topped out at 89 mph and might be a draft-and-follow.