Matt Blood and Nathan Rode. Am from New York and I saw that George
Washington High School(24) is in the Top 50 I wanted to ask you guys
how good is the team and how good is their C Jean Carlos Rodriguez?
also Who are other prospects that we may hear about this upcoming draft?
Greetings everyone. The high school season is upon us and its shaping
up to be exciting as always. Thanks for joining us in this chat. Matt
and I will do our best to answer your questions. Quick note: Texas and
California schools start this week, while Florida is already rolling.
Eric Hosmer is the hottest so far, with two home runs in his first two
games. It didn’t take long for opponents to avoid him as he has five
walks in his last two games. On to the questions….
George Washington has a competitive program and is the alma mater of
Manny Ramirez. This team is shaking out to be pretty good. They’ll make
a run at the city championship (they don’t participate in a state
tournament). JC Rodriguez will be the center of the team while Fernando
Frias will make some noise as well. Their coach has said Frias is “the
next Manny.” Lofty expectations, but enough to get some attention.
Karl of Delaware from Georgetown, Delaware asks:
Griffin or Griffith of Seaford High School in Delaware was a top 50
high school player per BaseballAmerica. He is a shortstop and I heard
he is going to North Carolina. How close did he come to making the 3rd
Hi everyone. Thanks for joining in with Nathan and me. This is my chat
debut, and I’m ready to take your best shot. Let’s just hope I fare
better than Joey Devine.
I believe the player you are referring to is Derrik Gibson. Yes, he is
a North Carolina signee and has their coaching staff very excited about
having him. Gibson came on strong at the end of the summer. He was most
impressive in Jupiter this past October at the WWBA. There were a few
other guys in front of him in regards to making the 3rd team, but he is
a guy to keep an eye on this season as everyone likes an athletic
shortstop with the ability to hit.
Tom from San Francisco, CA asks:
Do you have any idea if the Braves are targeting Xavier Avery at this point?
The Braves do have a tendency to scoop up the Georgia talent, however,
I believe Avery is on everyone’s target list. He has pure speed and is
a great athlete. I do know a team in the state of Georgia that is
targeting him for sure – the Georgia Bulldogs. Playing between the
hedges in Athens is a tough dream to let go, and be sure that whatever
team drafts Avery will be entering into a dual sport contract.
Mike Bradley from Orlando, Fl asks:
has been a lot of hype about Winter Springs HS, here in the Orlando
area. They have 8 early signees and 6 of those are D1. The finished up
in the top 15 last year. Wondering how they didn’t make the top 50?
Winter Springs made a good run last year, but got bounced in the state
semifinals of the 6-A tournament (highest in Florida). They didn’t make
the preseason poll this year because there some questions about the
team’s experience. Only four starters are returning and of the reserves
on the 2007 squad, only one player reached double digits in at-bats.
However, their two best pitchers are back, so we’re not counting them
out. They can still certainly gain some momentum and move up the polls
as the season plays out.
Jeremy from Alabama asks:
noticed where Casey Kelley is listed as undecided as to what school he
intends to sign with. I believe he verbally commited to sign with
Tennessee in football. Could he choose another school for baseball and
decide to attend that school instead?
He has not made a baseball commitment, though I have seen the reports
about Tennessee football. He absolutely could choose another school for
baseball and end up there. A verbal commitment is just that, verbal.
We’ve seen players de-commit. Kevin Rhoderick, Tim Alderson’s high
school counterpart ended up changing his mind on going to Georgia and
has already made his debut for the two-time champion Oregon State
Beavers. It will be interesting to see what Casey decides because he
could help schools in both sports.
David from Orlando asks:
I heard plenty of good things about MIF David Nick, is he a candidate to go high in the 2009 amateur draft?
It’s early to say, but David Nick is one of the top 30 guys in next
year’s class. His defense is smooth and he projects to be a good
hitter. He’s projected to be something close to the fifth middle
infielder taken in the ’09 draft.
Alex from New Hampshire asks:
How is Bobby Bundy from Sperry HS, OK, not an all american? a potential first rounder, i dont see how he was overlooked!!??
Easy there sport. These All-America teams are voted on by Major League
scouting directors, so I would double-check those first round
projections. He did receive a couple of third-team votes, but not
nearly enough to crack the first three teams.
Mick from Chicago asks:
Where would I have to go in the Chicagoland area to see some good position prospects?
Austin Wright is a lefthander from Conant HS in Hoffman Estates, just
west of Chicago. St. Rita’s also should play some good ball this year.
I’d wait for all that snow to clear out first though.
Non Roster Invitee from RTP, NC asks:
What asepcts of evaluating HS players differ from scouting college players?
The biggest difference between college and high school players is
obviously age. When you’re looking to draft a college guy, you are
going to try to evaluate what he can do for your big league team in 1-2
years, since they already have a few years of experience beyond HS
competition. High schoolers, you’re looking for projection. Does it
seem like their frame will fill out as they get older? Signability is
also a factor. High schoolers sometimes cost more because they can opt
to go to college, while college guys either have to get a year older if
they stay for their senior year, or they don’t have much of a
bargaining chip if they’re graduating.
David from Orlando asks:
Who are the five can’t-miss bats in this year’s draft class? What about next year’s draft class?
This year’s draft class has some exciting young hitters. Tim Beckham is
the best player in the class and has a tremendous bat. Eric Hosmer,
Kyle Skipworth, Adrian Nieto and Zack Cox are all other guys who can
really swing it. Skipworth and Nieto both play the catcher position,
making them a rare combination of field and hit at a premium position.
Next year, look for names like Mike Givens, Max Stassi, Jeff Malm,
Austin Maddox and Cooper Moseley.
Martin from Tampa Bay asks:
their any consideration for Seton Hall Prep (NJ) in the top 50? I know
they lost Porcello and others form last year but still return a lot of
They were discussed among our the members of our committee. They do
have some returning talent, but they were incredibly dominant last year
mostly because Porcello and Evan Danieli were basically untouchable.
They will definitely be on our radar, but will have to contend with
in-state rival Don Bosco.
Adam from NYC asks:
notable names left off the all-american team lists are Destin Hood and
Kyle Long. Is this a case of football committments hurting their
baseball rankings? Destin looked great the AFLAC classic, but it seems
his stock took a dive after that. Any word on the outlook for their
Destin Hood and Kyle Long are both intriguing guys for this year’s
draft. Hood is a great athlete who as some scouts say, “has lightening
in his bat.” A standout wide receiver in high school, Hood is committed
to play football at Alabama. You’re right, his stock did seem to
decrease, but he did not attend any more baseball events following the
Aflac All-American game. I’m guessing because of football. Long, the
son of Howie, has the mentality and the body of a football player.
However, he is a tremendous pitcher and has an undeniably intimidating
presence on the mound.
Both of these guys have a passion for baseball, and I wouldn’t be
surprised to see them both play baseball professionally in the future.
Greg from Los Angeles, CA asks:
seems like many of the top 50 are southern california boys, sweet! Has
the region become the top area for HS baseball throughout the country
or do regions like Florida or Texas still have a claim on that title?
California is part of what a lot of us know as The Big Three. I
mentioned before that Florida has already started their season. Texas
and Cali start this week. Weatherbug is telling me that its 40 degrees
in Durham, N.C. currently. The talent levels in these areas have a lot
to do with weather, but also concentration of people. The Big Three
have an advantage because they can start earlier and play all year,
allowing them to hone their skills. Also, there are larger populations
in these states, which gives you a larger sample to select players
from. However, there are states like Georgia and Arizona that are
quickly making a name, but you’ll have to wait until late-March to read
what Matt Blood found on that topic.
Merkado from White Plains, NY asks:
on the first team list, you have Harold Martinez listed at 3B. Is this
because of Beckham being more of a true SS prospect, or is Harold
likely to switch to 3B for good? Is a comparison to a young Alex
Rodrigues too lofty for Martinez?
Martinez is a guy with great fielding actions and ability. However, his
size and power projection make him fit more at the hot corner. Some
scouts feel Martinez will be a middle of the lineup hitter, winning
Gold Gloves in five years. A-Rod might be a lofty comparison, but in
the same context of switching positions, I could see the similarities.
I doubt Martinez will ever play shortstop in the Major Leagues though.
brandon from seattle, wa asks:
noticed there wasnt anybody from the state of washington in your
all-american list. i was just wondering if there are any decent players
out of the state this year?
That is a great question. After talking with scouts from the area, it
appears the state of Washington and the entire Northwest for that
matter, is having somewhat of a down year. However, Bryan Peterson,
Beau Brett and Andrew Kittredge are names to keep in mind
Futility Infielder from N C asks:
What specific skill set is the best measurement for high school players?
Somebody in Carolina has a clever mind for nicknames. Speed and arm
strength are good tools to look at for high schoolers. Those aspects
will typically stay with someone, barring injuries of course.
Projection, again, isn’t a skill really, but still very important.
Scouts will look at a player’s body and try to get an idea of whether
or not they think they will fill out or not.
ScottAZ from Phx, AZ asks:
If you had to guess, where will Hicks end up? Mound or OF? What about Gose?
If I had to guess…. Isn’t that the name of the entire game? For both
of those guys, I would say in the field. Even though they can each
touch 95 mph of the mound, they show the ability to be everyday impact
players. Both are tremendous athletes with great speed. The question
will be, can they hit professional pitching. If they prove they can,
they’ll be too valuable to put on the mound.
David from Orlando asks:
than the guys on the All-America teams, who among this year’s crop of
high schoolers has the best combination of stuff, pitchability and
A guy to really keep an eye on is California lefty Mike Montgomery.
He’s a good athlete and consistently pitches in the 90 mph range. He
has great upside and is very projectable. If he can gain consistency in
his breaking ball, he’ll move up the draft board.
james f from atlanta asks:
kids in the Atlanta area I’m curious to hear your thoughts on – OF/P
Jay Austin (N. Atlanta) and OF Billy Burns (Walton HS)? Austin, I
understand, is headed to USC. I haven’t heard mention of Burns, who I
suspect slips below the radar because of his 5-9 heighth.
Jay Austin is an intriguing player. With great speed and a quick
lefthanded bat, he should be able to find a way on base at every level.
He doesn’t show much projection for power. He also shows good instincts
in the outfield.
Burns size does play against him and he is the type of player that will
have to prove himself at every level.
Jonathan from GA asks:
How does Hosmer compare to Smoak and Alsono? Is the there a major leaguer to compare him to?
The difference between Hosmer and Smoak/Alonso is three years and
experience. Hosmer is the ’08 high school class’s best hitter. His
swing isn’t long and he is very patient at the plate. I would compare
him more to Alonso than Smoak. Both are similar in the fact that they
consistently make solid contact. In the Major Leagues, he could be a
Jason Giambi type.
JAYPERS from IL asks:
Does Destin Hood have a shot at getting picked in the 1st round and if so, which team needs his services the most?
The answer to this question is yes. Hood is a tremendous athlete with
Major League tools. If he decides to play only baseball and if
signability is not an issue, I could definitely see him going later in
the first round or supplemental. I wouldn’t say one specific team needs
his services or would draft him for that reason. Most teams draft on
the basis of who is the best player available that is signable and less
on actual need.
Blake from Kentucky asks:
Are any of the Kentucky commitments who are pre season All-Americans expected to make it to Lexington?
Kentucky’s recruiting class is impressive, loaded with top tier
pitching and some hitting. You’re hitting on a key note – the odds of
all of them going to school are low. Ross, Meyer and Webb are both
expected to be drafted in the first-round. Very seldom does a
first-round draft pick pass on the money for school. This recruiting
class reminds me of North Carolina’s trio last year of Porcello, Harvey
and Bumgarner. Harvey being the only one to show up on campus. The
Wildcats will be lucky to keep one of their big three this year.
greg from toronto asks:
At this point in time, how much separation is there between Aaron Hicks, Isaac Galloway, and Xavier Avery?
I think the separation comes in projection. Galloway is the most
polished and mature of the three at the present. However, Hicks is the
most projectable. Avery is behind both of these two in both categories.
Steve from Orlando,Fl asks:
Will the Rays seriously consider Beckham as the #1 overall pick in June?
Of course the Rays will consider Beckham. This year’s decision won’t be
as easy for R.J. Harrison and his staff as last year. The Rays do one
of the best jobs at considering all possibilities before making
Jonathan from GA asks:
So to follow up – if you were in a prospect league fantasy draft..Smoak, Alonso, Hosmer??
Kind of a fun question.
You could answer Melville v. Cole too!
Personally, I would take Alonso. The guy can flat out hit – power and
average. He’s further along than Hosmer in years – so you’ll see
production from him sooner. Melville vs. Cole? Well, Cole might reach
the big leagues sooner because of his power fastball, however, I would
take Melville for the long run. He is the most polished pitcher in this
DAN from INDIANAPOLIS asks:
you have any idea how many of the top level high school kids are Scott
Boras guys, and if so how that will affect their signability?
Boras seems to have a handful of top level players in every draft.
Gerrit Cole is one of Boras’s clients this year. Being a Boras guy
always has an effect on signability. He has affected the draft more
than any other agent in the history of the draft – good or bad.
Josh from Sulphur, LA asks:
for the chat. I see that Barbe is ranked no. 6 entering the season with
their offense cited as a strength. Will any of those bats go high
(first 10 rounds) in this year’s draft? Or is it just a case of a solid
HS players throughout the lineup?
Solid HS players through the lineup. They have one player committed to
Tulane, Ryan Doiron, a 3B/RHP who hit .383-9-47 in 2007. Two others are
committed to McNeese State, a mid-major D-I program and alma mater to
Ben Broussard. Barbe is consistently competitive so they get some good
attention. We’ll see how the season plays out though. There is plenty
of time for someone to pop up on scouts’ radars.
Anthony from Staten Island, NY asks:
Do the Mets focus on pitching or do they look for a big bat?
Last year, the Mets drafted pitchers with their first six picks. The
year before they took pitchers with their first five picks, and in 2005
they took Mike Pelfrey with their first pick. I’m sure the Mets focus
on both pitching and hitting, but over the past few years, you do the
RM Kirk from Los Angeles, CA asks:
How does the entire Aluminum vs Wood hitting ability figure in to evaluation of these top tier players? Is it relevant at all?
That debate is one that could get any scout talking, especially when it
comes to college players. The results of hitting with a wood bat are
more “true”. What is often times a jam shot single with aluminum would
almost always be a broken bat out with wood. However, with high school
players, scouting is mostly on projection. I have heard it said before
that the way a high schooler hits with aluminum is the way he’ll
eventually hit with wood when he matures.
Doug from Murrieta, CA asks:
how good is Cypress HS (CA) and what are their chances of beating Vista
Murrieta HS (CA)this year? I heard Cypress should have beaten them this
past year in the state playoffs..So if they meet again in the playoffs,
who do you guys like?
Not having Josh Vitters obviously doesn’t help the Centurions, but
there is still talent on this team. They have four D-I commits, several
regulars back and a transfer. David Nick (UCLA) hit .358-3-29 last year
and Chase Koissian (Hawaii) is another guy to watch. Danny Pulfer
transferred in and is committed to play at Oregon in the Ducks’
inaugural season. However, Koissian is out for another couple of weeks
after a run-in with a fence. RHP Dennis Waites was only a sophomore
last year when he went 8-1 with three saves. The talent is there, but
it will be a challenging season for Cypress. Right now, Vista Murrieta
seems to have the advantage, but everybody plays everybody differently.
Joe from Chantilly, VA asks:
there any consideration given to the Snyder twins in Northern Virginia
(brothers of 1st rounder Brandon Snyder) for the All-American team? I
know they are both big kids with good bloolines and great stats, but
are they players for teh first couple round of the draft?
The Snyder brothers didn’t get near the cut for one of the All-America
teams, but that is no discredit. They’ll obviously get some attention
because of their brother Brandon, but it looks like there is a good
chance they’ll be playing for Ole Miss this time next year.
That’s going to do it for today everyone. Thanks for the great
questions. Hopefully we can get some more high school chats in the
El Surdo from 951 asks:
Skipworth and Matt Lolis are teammates at the same So. Cal high school,
Riverside Patriot. Lolis is listed as playing at the wrong school,
Rubidoux, on all BA reports. Do you think Patiot HS has a chance to
duplicate Chatsworth High Schools Moustakas and Dominguez as possible
1st round HS teammates?
What Moustakas and Dominguez did last year was pretty amazing, and both
guys were consensus first-rounders going into the draft. I feel that
Skipworth is the same way and will be taken early. Lollis will have to
proove himself this spring. As of now, I do not see him in the
first-round. Thanks everyone for the questions. That’s all the time we
have for today. Talk with you again soon…