| Pick | Overall | Team | Player | Position | School | State |
| 1 | 416 | Washington Nationals | Tim Smalling | SS | Virginia Tech | Va. |
| 2 | 417 | Pittsburgh Pirates | Bryce Weidman | RHP | Southwestern Oregon CC | Ore. |
| 3 | 418 | Baltimore Orioles | Michael Mosby | 3B | Wabash Valley (Ill.) CC | Ill. |
| 4 | 419 | Kansas City Royals | Mike Giovenco | RHP | North Park (Ill.) | Ill. |
| 5 | 420 | Cleveland Indians | Diego Seastrunk | C | Rice | Texas |
| 6 | 421 | Arizona Diamondbacks | Ty Linton | OF | Charlotte (N.C.) Christian HS | N.C. |
| 7 | 422 | New York Mets | J.B. Brown | 2B | Pacific | Calif. |
| 8 | 423 | Houston Astros | Jordan Scott | OF | Riverside HS, Greer, S.C. | S.C. |
| 9 | 424 | San Diego Padres | Tommy Medica | C | Santa Clara | Calif. |
| 10 | 425 | Oakland Athletics | J.C. Menna | RHP | Brookdale (N.J.) CC | N.J. |
| 11 | 426 | Toronto Blue Jays | Dayton Marze | RHP | Louisiana-Lafayette | La. |
| 12 | 427 | Cincinnati Reds | Dan Wolford | RHP | California | Calif. |
| 13 | 428 | Chicago White Sox | Mike Blanke | C | Tampa | Fla. |
| 14 | 429 | Milwaukee Brewers | Mike Walker | 3B | Pacific | Calif. |
| 15 | 430 | Chicago Cubs | Colin Richardson | RHP | Winter Haven (Fla.) HS | Fla. |
| 16 | 431 | Tampa Bay Rays | Austin Hubbard | RHP | Auburn | Ala. |
| 17 | 432 | Seattle Mariners | Tyler Linehan | LHP | Sheldon HS, Sacramento | Calif. |
| 18 | 433 | Detroit Tigers | Patrick Cooper | RHP | Bradley | Ill. |
| 19 | 434 | Atlanta Braves | Richie Tate | RHP | Market Tree (Ark.) HS | Ark. |
| 20 | 435 | Minnesota Twins | DeAndre Smelter | RHP | Tattnall Square Academy, Macon, Ga. | Ga. |
| 21 | 436 | Texas Rangers | Nick Tepesch | RHP | Missouri | Mo. |
| 22 | 437 | Florida Marlins | Danny Black | 2B | Oklahoma | Okla. |
| 23 | 438 | San Francisco Giants | Raynor Campbell | 2B | Baylor | Texas |
| 24 | 439 | St. Louis Cardinals | Cesar Aguilar | RHP | Miller HS, Fontana, Calif. | Calif. |
| 25 | 440 | Colorado Rockies | Taylor Reid | RHP | St. Mary's | Calif. |
| 26 | 441 | Philadelphia Phillies | Chace Numata | C | Pearl City (Hawaii) HS | Hawaii |
| 27 | 442 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Alex McRee | LHP | Georgia | Ga. |
| 28 | 443 | Boston Red Sox | Mike Hollenbeck | C | Joliet Township (Ill.) HS | Ill. |
| 29 | 444 | Los Angeles Angels | James Sneed | OF | St. Croix Educational Complex, Christiansted, V.I. | V.I. |
| 30 | 445 | New York Yankees | Travis Dean | RHP | Newton (Mass.) South HS | Mass. |