| Pick | Overall | Team | Player | Position | School | State |
| 1 | 386 | Washington Nationals | Chris McKenzie | RHP | San Jacinto (Texas) JC | Texas |
| 2 | 387 | Pittsburgh Pirates | Chris Kirsch | LHP | Marple Newtown HS, Newtown Square, Pa. | Pa. |
| 3 | 388 | Baltimore Orioles | Jeremy Nowak | OF | Mount Olive (N.C.) | N.C. |
| 4 | 389 | Kansas City Royals | Jonathan Gray | RHP | Chandler (Okla.) HS | Okla. |
| 5 | 390 | Cleveland Indians | Michael Goodnight | RHP | Houston | Texas |
| 6 | 391 | Arizona Diamondbacks | Kevin Ziomek | LHP | Amherst (Mass.) Regional HS | Mass. |
| 7 | 392 | New York Mets | Brian Harrison | 3B | Furman | S.C. |
| 8 | 393 | Houston Astros | Davis Duren | 2B | Oklahoma State | Okla. |
| 9 | 394 | San Diego Padres | Miguel Pena | LHP | San Jacinto (Texas) JC | Texas |
| 10 | 395 | Oakland Athletics | A.J. Griffin | RHP | San Diego | Calif. |
| 11 | 396 | Toronto Blue Jays | Tyler Painton | LHP | Centennial HS, Bakersfield, Calif. | Calif. |
| 12 | 397 | Cincinnati Reds | Lucas O'Rear | RHP | Northern Iowa | Iowa |
| 13 | 398 | Chicago White Sox | Ethan Icard | RHP | Wilkes (N.C.) CC | N.C. |
| 14 | 399 | Milwaukee Brewers | Michael White | RHP | Walters State (Tenn.) CC | Tenn. |
| 15 | 400 | Chicago Cubs | Pierre LePage | 2B | Connecticut | Conn. |
| 16 | 401 | Tampa Bay Rays | Robby Price | 2B | Kansas | Kan. |
| 17 | 402 | Seattle Mariners | Jason Markovitz | LHP | Long Beach State | Calif. |
| 18 | 403 | Detroit Tigers | P.J. Polk | OF | Tennessee | Tenn. |
| 19 | 404 | Atlanta Braves | Brandon Drury | SS | Grants Pass (Ore.) HS | Ore. |
| 20 | 405 | Minnesota Twins | Ryan O'Rourke | LHP | Merrimack (Mass.) | Mass. |
| 21 | 406 | Texas Rangers | Andrew Clark | 1B | Louisville | Ky. |
| 22 | 407 | Florida Marlins | Kentrell Dewitt | OF | Southeastern (N.C.) CC | N.C. |
| 23 | 408 | San Francisco Giants | Tyler Christman | RHP | South Carolina-Sumter JC | S.C. |
| 24 | 409 | St. Louis Cardinals | Colin Walsh | 2B | Stanford | Calif. |
| 25 | 410 | Colorado Rockies | Josh Mueller | RHP | Eastern Illinois | Ill. |
| 26 | 411 | Philadelphia Phillies | John Hinson | 3B | Clemson | S.C. |
| 27 | 412 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Jesse Bosnik | 3B | St. Bonaventure | N.Y. |
| 28 | 413 | Boston Red Sox | Keith Couch | RHP | Adelphi (N.Y.) | N.Y. |
| 29 | 414 | Los Angeles Angels | Bryant George | RHP | Southern Illinois | Ill. |
| 30 | 415 | New York Yankees | Tyler Austin | C | Heritage HS, Conyers, Ga. | Ga. |