Baseball America | Blog | Baseball America Prospects Blog

Here are the picks in the 2012 Rule 5 draft, beginning with the Major League Phase.

MAJOR LEAGUE PHASE, ROUND 1
Pick	Team	Player	Previous Team
1	Astros	Josh Fields, rhp	Red Sox
With a fastball up to 97 mph, the 27-year-old Fields had the best year of his career after being a first-round pick in 2008. Improved control, which he showed late in 2012 is key to his chances to stick.
2	Cubs	Hector Rondon, rhp	Indians
Rondon missed most of 2012 after needing a second elbow surgery. When healthy, he shows good command of a low-90s fastball and tops out at 96.
3	Rockies	Danny Rosenbaum, lhp	Nationals
Rosenbaum has fringy stuff, but eats innings, fills up the strike zone and keeps hitters off balance with his quick tempo.
4	Twins	Ryan Pressly, rhp	Red Sox
Pressly shows the potential for three plus pitches—a fastball 91-94 mph range, a sharp slider and a deceptive changeup. He had success in Double-A after move to the bullpen
5	Indians	Chris McGuiness, 1b	Rangers
The Arizona Fall League MVP has a strong lefthanded swing and hit 23 home runs in Double-A this year. He's always shown the ability to get on-base with a good approach at the plate.
6	Marlins	Alfredo Silverio, of	Dodgers
Showed the potential for five average or better tools, but missed all of 2012 after a car accident resulted in a concussion and an elbow injury. If healthy, could be the safest bet to stick on big league roster.
*7	Red Sox (traded to Tigers)	Jeff Kobernus, 2b	Nationals
More advanced than the average Rule 5 pick, Kobernus can play solid defense at second, steal some bases (42 in 53 tries in 2012) and hit a little. He lacks power, but plays the game with a hard-edged, heady approach
8	Royals	Pass
9	Blue Jays	Pass
*10	Mets (traded to Tigers)	Kyle Lobstein, lhp	Rays
Highly-regarded coming out of high school, Lobstein lost some velocity his senior year and has never regained. He's now a pitchability lefty who works in and out and features a good changeup.
11	Mariners	Pass
12	Padres	Pass
13	Pirates	Pass
14	Diamondbacks	Starling Peralta, rhp	Cubs
Peralta's stuff picked up in 2012 as once 88-92 mph fastball now sits 92-94. He pairs that with a slider that shows flashes of being a plus pitch. Held RHB to .613 OPS in 2012, which may help in likely move to bullpen if he's going to stick.
15	Phillies	Ender Inciarte, of	Diamondbacks
Potential backup outfielder runs well enough and plays good enough defense to possibly stick as a useful pinch-runner/defensive replacement. The lefthanded hitter doesn't have much pop, will be overmatched at the plate.
16	Brewers	Pass
17	White Sox	Angel Sanchez, ss	Angels
Former big leaguer could be an inexpensive utilityman. With 568 big league games, is a known quantity as an adequate glove that can play multiple positions. His bat showed some improvement in 2012 at Triple-A Oklahoma City.
18	Dodgers	Pass
19	Cardinals	Pass
20	Tigers	Pass
21	Angels	Pass
22	Rays	Pass
23	Orioles	T.J. McFarland, lhp	Indians
Touch and feel lefthander has more stuff than most crafty lefties. He normally sits 88-90, but can touch a 92 at times, and he knows how to get the ball to sink or run. McFarland lacks a plus pitch, but might throw enough strikes to survive.
24	Rangers	Coty Woods, rhp	Rockies
Low-angle reliever can be tough on righthanders in part because he throws a little harder (88-92) than the average sidearmer. Dominated Double-A but fell apart after promotion to Triple-A in 2012. Decent changeup means he's not helpless against lefthanders.
25	Athletics	Pass
26	Giants	Pass
27	Braves	Pass
28	Yankees	Pass
29	Reds	Pass
30	Nationals	Pass
1	Astros	Nate Freiman, 1b	Padres
A 6-foot-7 first baseman with big power, Freiman ranked third in the Texas League with 24 home runs in 2012. A star for Team Israel in World Baseball Classic, scouts are concerned that Freiman struggles to catch up to premium velocity.
2	Cubs	Pass
3	Rockies	Pass
4	Twins	Pass
5	Indians	Pass
6	Marlins	Brauilo Lara, lhp	Rays
Lara has a lean, athletic build that produces a mid-90s fastball and a hard, downer curveball. He went 6-10, 5.71 in high Class A in 2012 so while the stuff is excellent, he's a long ways from being ready to help a big league club.
TRIPLE-A PHASE
Pick	Team	Player	Previous Team
1	Astros	Michael Burgess, of	Nationals
Once traded for Tom Gorzelanny, big power hasn't played in high minors
2	Cubs	Pass
3	Rockies	Pass
4	Twins	Mark Sobolewski, 3b	Blue Jays
Best defensive 3B in Eastern Lge smacked 20 HR & reached Triple-A
5	Indians	Pass
6	Marlins	Tyler Kehrer, lhp	Angels
Supp pick in 2009 struggles to find zone but strikes out his share of LHB
7	Red Sox	Jack McGeary, lhp	Nationals
Boston native has pitched 64 IP in three years in between injuries
8	Royals	Pass
9	Blue Jays	Sawyer Carroll, of	Padres
Physical lefty bat offers some on-base skills, some pop; good minors corner man
10	Mets	Pass
11	Mariners	Eric Farris, 2b	Brewers
Brewers 2007 4th-rd drafted by Jack Zduriencik; Good 2B glove, above-avg speed
12	Padres	Diego Goris, 3b	Royals
Part of Yamacio Navarro deal; more pop than average INF but swings at everything
13	Pirates	Ethan Hollingsworth, rhp	Royals
Four-pitch mix, sits 90-92 mph, but not many swings and misses; twice-traded
14	Diamondbacks	Pass
15	Phillies	Brendan Lafferty, lhp	Royals
Hard-throwing LHP hits 95 mph & secondary stuff is OK; needs to throw more strikes
16	Brewers	Pass
17	White Sox	Pass
18	Dodgers	Elevys Gonzalez, 3b	Pirates
Hit .206 in down year, but switch-hits, plays 3B & 2B, sprays ball around
19	Cardinals	Matt Cerda, 3b	Cubs
2008 fourth-rounder owns career .371 OBP in minors; 5-9, LHH pest
20	Tigers	Eliezer Mesa, of	Athletics
Plus range & wheels, went 25-for-29 in SB. Once part of deal for Mark Ellis.
21	Angels	Robert Widlansky, of	Orioles
Ranked near top of Eastern Lge with .404 OBP, .316 AVG, 35 2B, 64 BB
22	Rays	Pass
23	Orioles	Tom Boleska, rhp	Twins
Gaudy 11.3 SO/9, 5.3 SO/BB in indy American Assoc.; signed by Twins in Oct.
24	Rangers	Marquez Smith, 3b	Reds
Split 2012 between Mexican Lge & Double-A Portland; nice glove at 3B
25	Athletics	Tommy Mendonca, 3b	Giants
Known for power coming out Fresno State, 2009 2nd-rounder slugged just .367 this season
26	Giants	Scott Shuman, rhp	Rays
Pitches at 93-95 mph with power slider. Tough look for RHB (36 SO% at Double-A)
27	Braves	Pass
28	Yankees	Pass
29	Reds	Ryan Dennick, lhp	Royals
Former Tennessee Tech ace has seen stuff pick up as pro; good swingman candidate
30	Nationals	Pass
TRIPLE-A PHASE, ROUND 2
Pick	Team	Player
1	Astros	Cameron Lamb, rhp	Giants
Aussie has yet to pitch in full-season ball, but coming off solid season in Northwest Lge
2	Cubs	Pass
3	Rockies	Pass
4	Twins	Pass
5	Indians	Pass
6	Marlins	Pass
7	Red Sox	Jon Bachanov, rhp	White Sox
2007 supp pick signed by then-Angels, now-Red Sox scout Tom Kotchman
8	Royals	Pass
9	Blue Jays	Alvido Jimenez, rhp	Cubs
Stout righthander has spent last three seasons in AZL, yet to pitch above there
10	Mets	Pass
11	Mariners	Pass
12	Padres	Federico Castaneda, rhp	Royals
Mexican Lge vet pitching well in winter ball, features 91-93 mph fastball
13	Pirates	Pass
14	Diamondbacks	Pass
15	Phillies	Pass
16	Brewers	Pass
17	White Sox	Pass
18	Dodgers	Hector Nelo, rhp	Nationals
Double-plus fastball bumps 96 mph. Allowed .229 AVG, 1.8 G/F in Double-A
19	Cardinals	Jay Voss, lhp	Tigers
Missed most of 2012 after TJ surgery; Fringy stuff, good control when healthy
20	Tigers	Pass
21	Angels	Pass
22	Rays	Pass
23	Orioles	Pass
24	Rangers	Pass
25	Athletics	Steve Hill, c	Cardinals
A catcher early in career, playing corner INF and OF lately; has MLB experience
26	Giants	Pass
27	Braves	Pass
28	Yankees	Pass
29	Reds	Michael Gilmartin, ss	Athletics
Fringy defender with avg arm; one of 10 players in Cal Lge with 400+ PA, sub-.700 OPS
30	Nationals	Pass
TRIPLE-A PHASE, ROUND 3
Pick	Team	Player
1	Astros	Pass
2	Cubs	Pass
3	Rockies	Pass
4	Twins	Pass
5	Indians	Pass
6	Marlins	Pass
7	Red Sox	Pass
8	Royals	Pass
9	Blue Jays	Efrain Nieves, lhp	Tigers
Brewers 7th-rounder out of P.R. in 2007, Nieves has just 63 IP above low Class A