PHOENIX—For most of their careers, Baltimore’s Josh Bell and Brandon Snyder have been known as defensive liabilities.
Coming into the season, Bell appeared to be a likely candidate to move off of third base, while Snyder was a below-average defender at first base after trying his hand at catching earlier in his career.
That perception is changing.
Phoenix manager Gary Cathcart saw Bell in the low Class A Midwest League in 2007, when Cathcart managed Lansing and Bell played for Great Lakes in the Dodgers organization. Bell committed 35 errors in 90 games at third base that season, and questions lingered until this season about whether Bell would eventually move off the position.
Now those questions seem to have vanished. Bell, 23, has slimmed down considerably from his listed 6-foot-3, 235 pounds and become a more reliable defender at third base, even winning the Best Defensive Third Baseman honor from Double-A Southern League managers in Baseball America’s Best Tools survey. He’s always had an above-average arm, but those who have followed Bell this season say his actions look cleaner and his improved conditioning has helped his range.
"(In the Midwest League) I saw a big, young kid, a switch-hitter with power-hitting potential," said Cathcart, who also saw Bell this year in the Eastern League while managing the Blue Jays’ Double-A New Hampshire club. "Then I did get to see him this year, two years later, and he looked like a totally different guy. Just in those three years since I’ve seen him, he’s gotten himself in shape, his footwork at third base is night and day where it was. He’s always had pretty good hands, but he’s a legitimate third baseman now defensively."
With his ability to stick at third base, Bell’s value has soared. Bell hit .296/.386/.497 in 94 games for Double-A Chattanooga, then continued to rake to a .298/.346/.570 tune in 33 games for Double-A Bowie after the Dodgers traded him and righthander Steven Johnson to the Orioles for lefty George Sherrill.
"To me it’s all about a consistent approach with him," Cathcart said. "He’s got tremendous power, tremendous power from both sides. The sound off his bat is truly major league. It’s just going to be a matter of being consistent with his approach and getting good pitches to hit. I know a lot of people have talked to him about getting himself out more often than not on pitchers’ pitches. It’s something he’s going to need to learn, especially facing a higher level of pitching, but all the tools are there for him to be a pretty good big leaguer."
Snyder, who turns 23 next week, was regarded as a work in progress in the field with below-average range and footwork at first base. Yet it’s Snyder’s glovework that has stood out the most to his Desert Dogs manager.
"What I didn’t realize is how good a defender he is at first base," Cathcart said. "He really prepared for it every day, worked real hard in pre-game. He’s got real good feet and real, real quick hands. He made some tremendous plays for us defensively here the whole time he was here. He’s got a chance to be a pretty impact big leaguer here pretty quick. I’m sure Baltimore’s pretty excited about him."
Snyder, who left the team last week because of a family commitment, hit .354/.456/.600 in 17 games and walked (13) more than he struck out (11). He was outstanding during the minor league season with Double-A Bowie, where he hit .343/.421/.597 in 55 games, then struggled upon a promotion to Triple-A Norfolk with a 248/.316/.355 batting line in 73 games.
"Brandon is probably as polished, as advanced a hitter as I saw in this league," Cathcart said. "He has a tremendously consistent batting practice approach every day, really works on his swing path and has a real, real good idea on how to hit. He was probably our best overall hitter as far as having a consistent approach."
|
Comments will be monitored prior to being added to the site. Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be rejected. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. We have chosen to open up commenting to everyone, so comment away! We want to hear from each and every one of you! Leave a comment. |
About This Blog
Categories
Archives
Syndicate This Blog
Blogs
BaseballAmerica.com
Search This Blog
Great piece Ben. Hopefully Snyder and Bell can join the O’s soon. Any idea when you think they will be ML ready? And what’s a good comparison for Snyder? Kotchman? Thanks
Posted by Steveospeak | November 17, 2009 at 12:22 pm | ShortcutBen, Cathcart offers a glowing report on Snyder’s bat and even his glove, describing him as becoming a “pretty impact big leaguer.”
Looking back at Will Lingo’s write up in the 2009 Handbook had Snyder’s value tied exclusively to his bat, emphasizing his poor range and footwork at the bag and possibly projecting as moving to the outfield.
Evaluators seem to be divided on not only his path to the big leagues, but his ceiling. What do you see in Snyder? And do you personally think the “bad glove” label should be removed, or at least reconsidered?
Posted by Casey | November 17, 2009 at 1:36 pm | ShortcutWhere would you rank Bell and Synder amongst the Orioles prospects after their AFL stint.
Just below Matusz and Britton?
Thanks
Posted by JollyRoger | November 17, 2009 at 2:38 pm | ShortcutCasey- Coming into the season, yes, there were definitely concerns about Snyder’s defense. But I think a player can improve defensively to a greater degree than he can at the plate if he’s willing to put in the work and he has certain indispensable tools for the position he plays. For some reason, Chase Utley always comes to mind for me as an example, but there are others who have gone from guys with questionable fielding skill to above-average defenders at their positions.
The opinion in the story is just Cathcart’s view (Snyder was done in the AFL by the time I got out there), but he’s worked with him every day for a month now and, more than anything, he really seemed impressed by Snyder’s fielding. (He managed in the Eastern League this year, too, but Bowie never played New Hampshire while Snyder was there in the first half.) While it’s just one opinion, I’d certainly say it’s a solid piece of evidence that points to Snyder’s improved skill in the field.
Posted by Ben Badler | November 17, 2009 at 4:09 pm | ShortcutJollyRoger- I’ll wait until our Orioles Top 10 list comes out next month, but Bell has really, really raised his stock in my eyes (and for others as well) with his defensive transformation.
Posted by Ben Badler | November 17, 2009 at 4:22 pm | Shortcut