Good News For Bubble Dwellers



Favorites have come up big in the early games today, giving some hope to fringe at-large contenders. We’ll break down the bubble teams at the bottom of this post, but first here’s a look at today’s big news:

• Middle Tennessee State has won the Sun Belt Conference tournament with a 3-1 win over Louisiana-Monroe, ensuring the Sun Belt will be no more than a two-bid league (if Western Kentucky gets in—which is very much in question, in light of WKU’s 1-6 record against the top 50 RPI teams).

• In the Big East, Louisville cruised to an 11-3 win over Connecticut, which will probably make the Big East a one-bid league, though Notre Dame does have a shot at an at-large berth.

• Rice held off a late Southern Mississippi rally to win the Conference USA title 8-6. The Owls might have earned the eighth national seed with their strong week. Southern Miss is right on the bubble, but its strong week and slightly better RPI might give it the edge over Tulane for Conference USA’s third bid (though I think Tulane is more deserving, for reasons stated in my comment at the bottom of this post). It’s hard to see CUSA getting four bids with so many other strong at-large candidates floating around.

• Jacksonville beat Lipscomb 7-4 to win the Atlantic Sun title. The Dolphins have a top-50 RPI and might have had a shot at an at-large spot, but their victory today ensures the A-Sun will be a one-bid league.

There are no other championship games left to play where a potential at-large team is facing a team that can only make regionals by winning the automatic bid. So, let’s assume Georgia Southern is in whether it beats Elon today or not. And let’s award bids to the top eight teams in the SEC; the top seven in the ACC (with Boston College earning the final one over Duke); the top six in the Big 12 (with Kansas getting the nod over Baylor); the top three in the Big West and Big Ten; and the top two in the Mountain West, Pac-10, Southland and SoCon.

That leaves 57 bids are accounted for, leaving the following candidates for the final seven spots (listed in order of RPI, as of this morning on warrennolan.com):

Baylor (29)
George Mason (40)
Oregon State (45)
Western Kentucky (46)
Notre Dame (47)
San Diego State (51)
Western Carolina (52)
Southeastern Louisiana (54)
Southern Miss (55)
San Diego (56)
Rhode Island (57)
Hawaii (61)
Missouri State (64)
Tulane (66)
Eastern Illinois (69)
Duke (70)
San Jose State (75)
The Citadel (77)

Out of that group, I rank the seven leading candidates as follows, in order of likelihood to get a bid, with each team’s case in a nutshell in parentheses):

1. San Diego State (40 wins, reached MWC finals, has the game’s marquee player)
2. George Mason (won CAA regular-season title in dominating fashion, strong RPI)
3. Missouri State (MVC regular-season champ, nonconference series wins over Oregon State, Oral Roberts)
4. Western Kentucky (tied for regular-season crown in solid Sun Belt Conference, reached SBC tourney finals)
5. Rhode Island (A-10 runner-up in regular season and tourney, quality wins against Miami, Ohio State, Oklahoma State)
6. Eastern Illinois (OVC regular-season champ, wins against Oklahoma, Indiana, South Florida and a series against Southeastern Louisiana)
7. Oregon State (series win against Arizona State, but needs to beat Stanford today to avoid losing five of last six series)

I’ll have my final full field of 64 projection later this afternoon, after regional hosts are announced at 3:30 ET.



Comments

Comments will be monitored prior to being added to the site. Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be rejected. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed.

We have chosen to open up commenting to everyone, so comment away! We want to hear from each and every one of you! Leave a comment.

9 Comments

Is there any reason why you now only have Conference USA only getting Rice and ECU in? The other day you had Tulane in and earlier you were discussing the merits of Tulane and USM. Is it just a case of there being more-deserving at large teams than the CUSA pair?

I cannot believe that Ohio state is clear cut tournament team. They only won one game in their conference tourney and I just looked at their pathetic excuse for a schedule. The only team that they played in the regular season that is truly deserving of a bid is Louisville a team that destroyed OSU in both meetings. The only other team you could make a claim for his Minnesota and they beat OSU two out of three. Until recently Ohio State was considered a candidate to host. If they are being favored because of their high number of wins why aren’t all 40 win teams automatically in. San Diego State has 40 wins too and a much more difficult schedule. Why are they still on the bubble? Is too big a deal being made for cold weather schools with decent records?

Correct… though I still can’t shake the feeling CUSA gets another team in. Need to study this more before posting my final projections.

Your points are very valid.

I think Missouri State deserves to be in this year. They finished 9-1 down the stretch with OOC wins over Oregon State (2), Missouri, Oklahoma State & Oral Roberts. They started the year 4-10 because of injuries including the Valley player of year & narrowly lost to Creighton in the MVC tourney 7-6 in 10 innings after losing their starting catcher and one of the teams best bats to a broken bone in his face after getting hit by a pitch the day before. MSU is very good and would do well in the NCAA if given the opportunity. I hope they get the chance this year.

Missouri State is very deserving of an at-large bid. They beat the good non-conference teams they played. They started off slow but won 30 of their last 40. Hopefully the committee will take account of the fact Missouri State did not have one of their best hitters for the conference tournament when he was hit in the face his during his first at-bat of the tourny. He will be fine to play in a regional. The slow start can be attributed to the fact they did not have the Missouri Valley’s Player of the year Brayden Drake, playing because he had an injured wrist

Duke deserves an at large bid. They have 13 wins against top 50 RPI teams. There are only 15 teams in the country with more quality wins. They have two wins over Geargia Tech, Boston college, North Carolina, Clemson. They also beat Miami and Virginia and lost two close games to each of those teams.

The RPI stats are baffling to me. BYU (30-24) has a higher RPI then Duke (35-24). BYU’s record agains top 50 is 0-12, while Dukes is 13-13.

Terrific points, Nick. Duke deserves serious consideration. It’s too bad their horrendous nonconference schedule kills their RPI, because no bubble teams have more impressive series wins than beating Ga. Tech and UNC.

how can NEW MEXICO STATE win 48 games with only 17 losses and be ranked 140 in the rankings.
this proves that ranks are garbage…why does everybody always talk about the big name schools all the time…a team in the big12,& sec..will get teams that don’t deserve a bid just to make those conferences happy..a team like VANDERBILT which back in to the tournament..did not win the tournament but did get to the final…why reward a team for falling short….thanks


What Are Your Thoughts?

• Line and paragraph breaks are automatic
• Your e-mail address will never be displayed











About This Blog

  • Aaron Fitt is the lead college writer for Baseball America. If you have questions or comments about college baseball you can e-mail him at collegeblog@baseballamerica.com.

Categories

Archives

Syndicate This Blog

Blogs

BaseballAmerica.com

Search This Blog